Bay Area/ Oakland/ Crime & Emergencies
AI Assisted Icon
Published on May 10, 2024
Alameda County DA Charges Progressive and USAA Among Others in Alleged Car Insurance SchemeSource: Google Street View

Big trouble for big insurance. Alameda County's lead prosecutor, Pamela Price, has slapped a lawsuit on several auto insurers, software companies, including Progressive Insurance and USAA, and tech developers CCC Information Systems and Mitchell International. The suit charges that they've been working hand-in-glove to shortchange California drivers on payouts for totaled cars, according to a 69-page complaint unveiled last month.

The gritty details: these companies are accused of using rigged software to lowball the value of wrecked vehicles, dealing a hard blow to folks who depend on their cars for everything, the Alameda County District Attorney's Office stated. "A vehicle is the lynchpin to life in California," Price said, and fiddling with insurance payouts could lead to missed loan payments, dinged credit scores, job loss, or worse. The complaint lays out the dirty laundry: insurers used the suspect software to churn out "independent" valuations, then strong-armed customers with take-it-or-leave-it settlement offers, leaving many in the lurch.

The complaint also suggests that once insurers get customers to cave, they can flip the totaled cars at auction, minimizing their cash outlay. It's a sly move that lets them profit while allegedly leaving California's car owners and businesses high and dry, facing skewed vehicle values and repair shops missing out on business.

The DA's office isn't just throwing shade; they're after penalties, paybacks for shorted consumers, and an injunction to end these shady practices—the whole nine yards. And if that wasn't enough, the suit suggests this alleged chicanery hits disadvantaged groups, including seniors and people of color, the hardest; California law could pile on extra penalties for preying on these protected classes.

Angelenos and other Golden Staters who smell a rat with their insurance payouts can fight back. They've set up a hotline – just fill out the Consumer Fraud Complaint Form on the DA's site and let justice do its thing.