Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries

Indulge on New American fare at these top Columbus eateries
Third And Hollywood. | Photo: Alina A./Yelp
By Hoodline - Published on May 21, 2019.

Looking for a delicious New American meal near you?

Hoodline crunched the numbers to find the best high-end New American restaurants around Columbus, using both Yelp data and our own secret sauce to produce a ranked list of where to satisfy your cravings.

1. Third And Hollywood

Photo: Alina A./Yelp

Topping the list is Third and Hollywood. Located at 1433 W. Third Ave. in Tri-Village, the New American spot is the highest rated high-end New American restaurant in Columbus, boasting 4.5 stars out of 503 reviews on Yelp. 

The restaurant features brunch and dinner menus, along with a wide variety of wine, beer, cocktails and non-alcoholic beverages. For brunch, try the deep dish French toast with baked brioche, berries and vanilla whipped cream. For dinner, sample the rainbow trout with fried capers. Daily entree specials include housemade gnocchi and zin-braised short ribs.

2. Mitchell's Ocean Club

Photo: Christina H./Yelp

Next up is Easton's Mitchell's Ocean Club, situated at 4002 Easton St. With 4.5 stars out of 382 reviews on Yelp, the New American spot and steakhouse, serving seafood and more, has proven to be a local favorite for those looking to indulge. 

Mitchell's dinner menu offers appetizers, a raw bar, soups and salads, sushi, chicken, lamb, steaks and seafood that can be paired with 16 different sides from smoked gouda tater tots to roasted Brussel sprouts. A gluten-free menu and a young adult menu are also featured, in addition to an extensive selection of alcoholic beverages and desserts. Save room for the ten-layer carrot cake or the chocolate peanut butter pie.

3. Lindey's

Photo: Shuang S./Yelp

German Village Commission's Lindey's, located at 169 E. Beck St., is another top choice, with Yelpers giving the New American spot and wine bar four stars out of 604 reviews. 

Lindey's offers regular, gluten-free and children's menus for brunch, lunch and dinner. Order the fried chicken and waffles with strawberries and jalapeno maple syrup for brunch. Prefer a gluten-free selection for dinner? Try the shrimp and lobster risotto with grilled asparagus. The beverage menu features a lengthy list of wine, beer and signature cocktails.

4. Service Bar

Photo: Gus w./Yelp

Service Bar, a New American spot and cocktail bar in Weinland Park, is another pricey go-to, with four stars out of 74 Yelp reviews. Head over to 1230 Courtland Ave. to see for yourself.

Executive Chef Avishar Barua brings an eclectic menu to patrons of Service Bar, with items such as a red cabbage Caesar salad, lamb dumplings, short ribs and duck. Cocktails and desserts round out the offerings.

5. G. Michaels Bistro & Bar

Photo: Miriam F./Yelp

Last but not least, there's G. Michaels Bistro & Bar, a German Village Commission favorite with four stars out of 222 reviews. Stop by 595 S. Third St. to hit up the New American spot and bar next time you're looking to splurge. 

G. Michael's focuses on serving local and seasonal food inspired by the South's "low-country" flair, according to the restaurant's website. Try the shrimp and grits or the broiled swordfish paired with a chopped salad. 

This story was created automatically using local business data, then reviewed and augmented by an editor. Click here for more about what we're doing. Got thoughts? Go here to share your feedback.