The trial of Gregory Livingston, the former security guard charged with first-degree murder in the death of Alvin Motley Jr. at an East Memphis Kroger gas station, commenced with opening statements on Tuesday, as reported by Action News 5. The incident, which unfolded over a dispute involving loud R&B music, took a fatal turn when Livingston allegedly shot Motley, a 48-year-old Chicago man, on August 7, 2021.
Livingston,57, faces a first-degree murder charge after the altercation with Motley. His girlfriend, Pia Foster, stated that the argument escalated while she was pumping gas. According to Foster's testimony reported by FOX13 Memphis, “I observed the weapon being discharged and Alvin falling to the ground,” as emotions ran high in the courtroom.
Leading the defense, Leslie Ballin entered a not-guilty plea arguing that Livingston acted in self-defense, fearing for his life, while the prosecution presented a different narrative. Special Prosecutor Glenn Funk argued that the situation did not warrant lethal force, questioning, “What could Alvin Motley have done? Blown a smoke ring at him?” per courtroom coverage by Local Memphis. Funk insisted that Motley, holding a beer and a cigarette, was not a credible threat to justify the shooting.
The state prosecution is leaning heavily on the video and audio evidence that captures the heated exchange, asserting the action was premeditated and intentional. Additionally, the fact that Motley was legally blind and might not have even been aware that Livingston was armed was highlighted during the proceedings. As Foster recounted the moments leading to the shooting, she recalled feeling targeted by Livingston's hostility, saying, "One thing I do recall saying was ‘Leave us the F alone,’” according to the testimony obtained by Local Memphis.
The trial continues to draw public attention and is set to resume Wednesday morning. As the court delves deeper into the events of that August day, the defense and prosecution will present their narratives to the jury, who must then determine the fate of Gregory Livingston.
