Fredericksburg is a Texan town well-known for its German roots and quaint charm, but according to the latest food critiques, not all that glitters is gold in the local dining scene. Food critic Mike Sutter recently took a deep dive into Fredericksburg eateries, churning out a list of the town's top dining spots – as well as the ones that failed to hit the mark.
In the shadow of an impending solar eclipse and the predictable influx of tourists, Sutter's findings provide a guide to the best and worst of Fredericksburg's restaurants. Hondo's on Main, a 20-year-old establishment that seems to lean heavily on the vibe of a bygone era, was described as a place you'd visit "for the mood, not the food," according to Express News. There, the culinary offerings, such as its chicken-fried steak and chili, were compared to the disappointing fare you might expect from a roadside chain – not exactly a glowing endorsement.
Other disappointments included The Auslander, with its "grocery store" reminiscent German Snack plate and lackluster jägerschnitzel, and August E's, a relic that seems to have overstayed its welcome. Cabernet Grill, despite sporting a solid wine list, was said to have underwhelming dishes, like an overpriced surf-and-turf. Burger Burger also landed on Sutter's list for its steeply-priced and remarkably average burgers.
It wasn't all bad news, though, with Sutter spotlighting some standout options where the food is worth the bucks. At the top of the list is Otto's German Bistro, serving up dishes such as duck schnitzel that caught Sutter's palate. This eatery, alongside a lineup of honorable mentions, exhibits the diversity of Fredericksburg's better offerings – with flavors ranging from barbecue to Mediterranean and Italian, according to Express News.
While some locals may take issue with Sutter's blunt critiques, the writer extended an olive branch, advocating readers to support the places they love, whether they made his lists or not. As for tourists looking to get the most out of the Fredericksburg dining scene post-eclipse, Sutter's reviews offer a roadmap to navigate between the genuinely charming local joints and the tourist traps. Whether it's the German food at one of the town's many themed restaurants or a bite of something a bit more international, there's a meal in Fredericksburg to satisfy a variety of preferences – just be sure to research before you reserve.
