Edward O’Brien, now 44 years old, has spent almost three decades behind bars for the 1995 murder of Janet Downing, his neighbor in Somerville. At just 15 years old, O’Brien was charged with first-degree murder after Downing was found stabbed 98 times. Given a life sentence without the possibility of parole, O’Brien’s fate seemed sealed until Massachusetts’ highest court opened the door for juveniles convicted of murder to seek parole. WCVB reports that the parole board is expected to decide his case within 60 to 90 days.
Drawing on newly granted legal opportunities, O’Brien expressed his hope before the state parole board that he would be deemed safe to rejoin society. "I hope, after this hearing, this board will be comfortable allowing me back into society and rejoining my family and friends," O'Brien said, according to 7NEWS. Despite maintaining his innocence and promising to file an appeal, Janet Downing’s children vehemently argued against his release, citing ongoing fears for their safety.
O’Brien has repeatedly denied his involvement in the murder. During his parole hearing, he told the board, "I will not be a threat to any community," a sentiment he had previously shared in a prison interview with 7NEWS back in 2015. Meanwhile, his attorney, Jack Cunha, described O’Brien as "a good guy," who should be released from prison, as noted in a 7NEWS report. However, the Downing family remains unconvinced, with Janet Downing’s son, Ryan, telling reporter, "We feel our safety is in danger. He already killed my mom — there's no telling what he could do next," according to WCVB.
The case continues to draw public interest as it challenges perceptions of juvenile sentencing and parole possibilities. With O’Brien steadfast in his claims of being wrongfully convicted — an assertion he reiterated to the parole board — the stage is set for a critical decision. This decision will balance considerations of justice, redemption, and community safety. Janet Downing’s children express their opposition not just in terms of loss but also in fear of future harm. The parole board will soon conclude another chapter in a story that has lingered for nearly three decades.
