Why Doesn’t Hoodline Include A Suspect’s Race In Crime Stories?

Photo: Walter Thompson/Hoodline
By Walter Thompson - Published on September 11, 2017.

Readers frequently ask why we don’t include detailed descriptions of suspects in our neighborhood crime coverage.

Like other news organizations, we include a suspect's physical description if there's detailed and credible information that can help a reader identify someone. The overwhelming majority of police reports, however, contain only an estimate of a suspect’s age and race.

When police release detailed descriptions, surveillance photos, videos or sketches of criminal suspects, we share that information with readers. And in cases where a suspect or victim’s race is a factor, such as a hate crime, we’ll report that information as well.

Here’s an example of a SFPD crime report:

Call Type: Robbery

Date: 9/18/16

Time: 0726 hrs.

Case#: 160757315

Location: 700 blk. Taraval

District: Taraval

Suspect(s): HM 25-35

Suspect Vehicle: N/A

Weapon Type: N/A

Arrest: No

Victim(s): HM 55, Store

Injury: Redness in the chest, refused medical

Condition: Non-life threatening

Loss: Socks

M.O./Summary: S entered the store and socks in his shirt. V told the S to put the socks back and leave. S punched V in the chest and then fled.

Here’s how we reported the incident:

A 55-year-old man was punched in the chest by a 25 to 35-year-old man in a store on the 700 block of Taraval Street, after his assailant attempted to shoplift a pair of socks by putting them in his shirt. The victim refused medical attention.

A recent American Community Survey estimated that there are 105,463 men in San Francisco between the ages of 25 and 34, and that the city’s population is about 15 percent Hispanic or Latino.

As a result, "HM 25–35" describes more than 15,000 people, so including it in the story wouldn’t have been helpful.

This is a long-standing practice; in 2000, The Chronicle ran an editorial noting that racial descriptions “did nothing to advance the search for the suspect and everything to advance stereotypes about race.”

Because it’s difficult to determine a suspect’s race, “it is most likely smarter to leave it out, especially when you are making the information public,” said SFPD Captain John Sanford, who manages Park Station.

“I do not believe there is any empirical evidence that suggests if the public knows the race of an actual suspect, it increases the chances of taking that suspect into custody,” he told Hoodline via email.

Additionally, if police spread inaccurate information, it “could be challenged in court," he said.

“I encourage the community to always be on the lookout for suspicious and/or criminal activity and report that information immediately,” he added. “To me, this appears to be the best method, so we do not inappropriately profile anyone.”

If you have questions or feedback about this editorial policy, let us know in the comments, or send a note to [email protected]

About 4 hours ago
San Francisco Embarcadero Financial District

‘Nash Bridges’ reboot movie shoot electrifying the Financial District

The old combination of Don Johnson and Cheech Marin is bringing new life to downtown San Francisco, in the form of gunshots and exploding cars for the “Nash Bridges” made-for-TV movie. Read More

About 4 hours ago
San Francisco

Bay Area restaurants will hold 'Dining for India' fundraiser to raise funds for India COVID-19 relief efforts

In light of India’s catastrophic second Covid-19 wave, ten local Indian eateries have partnered together to donate 50% of their sales on May 25 toward COVID-19 response efforts in India. Read More

About 5 hours ago
San Francisco

California is set to rescind mask mandates next month, but Bay Area counties likely to sort out their own new rules

With California less than a month away from its "full-reopening" on June 15, and after the Centers for Disease Control rescinded its mask mandate last week, it's still not clear what a mostly vaccinated, maskless, post-pandemic Bay Area will look like. Read More

May 14, 2021
San Francisco Embarcadero Fisherman's Wharf

Watch: The F-Line ‘Boat Tram’ returns with ribbon-cutting celebration

The Blackpool Boat Tram popularly known as “Boat Boi” returned to the rails Friday, in advance of this weekend’s reopening of Muni Metro service and stations. Read More