New York City

Romanian Tennis Star Sorana Cirstea's Trophy Mysteriously Vanishes from NYC Hotel During U.S. Open

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 01, 2025
Romanian Tennis Star Sorana Cirstea's Trophy Mysteriously Vanishes from NYC Hotel During U.S. OpenSource: Wikipedia/Nuță Lucian from Cluj-Napoca, Romaniaderivative work: Kacir, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In a string of events that seems like a fault just outside the line of regular mishaps, Romanian tennis player Sorana Cirstea has reported that her recently won Cleveland trophy vanished from her New York City hotel room during the U.S. Open. In an Instagram post that echoed beyond the social media courts, Cirstea detailed the disappearance from her room at The Fifty Sonesta, pleading, "Whoever stole my Cleveland trophy from room 314 at The Fifty Sonesta please give it back!" CBS News New York relayed her sentiment, adding, "It has NO material value, just sentimental value. It would be (greatly) appreciated!"

While an ace on the tennis courts, Cirstea found herself playing defense against an unseen opponent. After clinching her third career singles title in the Cleveland warmup tournament earlier this month, she faced a setback when eliminated by No. 11 seed Karolina Muchova at Flushing Meadows only to find her victory's symbol missing. CBS News New York reports that The Fifty Sonesta team, headed by a director of safety and security who is a retired NYPD detective, is on the case, stating, "We are in close communication with our valued guest regarding the reported missing item."

The hotel's involvement contrasts slightly with the rather curt response of "the hotel said it had no comment" as mentioned by NY1. Yet, what remains clear is the 35-year-old's plea for the return of an object whose value isn't benchmarked by dollars but by the personal triumphs it represents.

Moving ahead, while the case of the purloined trophy plays out behind the scenes, the games continue on the courts. Sorana Cirstea's departure has left room for tennis aficionados to focus on fierce matchups such as Naomi Osaka versus Coco Gauff and Amanda Anisimova's evening face-off against Beatriz Haddad Maia. CBS News New York inadvertently placed Ekaterina Alexandrova and Iga Swiatek in the wrong stadium, commenting in anticipation of their contest, "Ekaterina Alexandrova faces Iga Swiatek in women's singles at 1 p.m. at Louis Armstrong Stadium."