Amid the pomp of self-congratulation over rising STAAR scores within the Houston Independent School District (HISD), a chorus of dissent rings out from parents and students alike, frustrated at what they perceive as mismanagement and misplaced priorities. HISD Board meetings have become an emotional battleground, with parents openly criticizing the actions of Superintendent Mike Miles, as reported by Click2Houston. Despite acknowledging improvements in high school subjects like Biology, Algebra, both English I and II, and U.S. History, the community's concerns lie elsewhere.
Specifically, a contentious issue involves the firing of a librarian from Harvard Elementary which left many questioning the district’s commitment to its educators. While Miles showcased the positive changes under his tenure, stating, “This has never been done in Texas," HISD student Eliana Gottlieb remained unimpressed. "They are not learning in ways that benefit children," Gottlieb told Click2Houston, driving home her point of systemic flaws in the educational process, which extends beyond mere test performance.
However, preliminary results previously shared add another dimension to this narrative. The Houston Chronicle reports that Houston ISD's third through eighth graders showcased marked improvements on math and reading STAAR exams. "I want to really emphasize our kids. They have stepped up, and their teachers have stepped up," said Miles, emphasizing the role of engagement and determination. Gains were seen in various grade levels and subjects, as mentioned in the Houston Chronicle.
Contrasts are clear when comparing the state averages and HISD's performance. The district, for the first time, surpassed the statewide average in four math exams. Still, skepticism persists, especially when it comes to resource allocation. Investigations by both the Texas Education Agency and the Harris County District Attorney’s Office were spurred by reports into the district spending up to $2 million to hire a strategic communications and political firm for a bond initiative, as noted by Click2Houston. While Miles celebrated "thousands of students" now reading and doing math at grade level, detractors voice concern over the true cost of these academic victories, as per a report by the Houston Chronicle.
