Columbus

Ohio Attorney General Sues Lancaster Dealership for Withholding Car Titles from Customers

AI Assisted Icon
Published on December 04, 2025
Ohio Attorney General Sues Lancaster Dealership for Withholding Car Titles from CustomersSource: Google Street View

Ohio's roads to car ownership have hit a legal pothole for one used-car dealership in Lancaster. The Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost has dropped the gavel on LLY Auto Sales and its operators, Luis Rafael and Luis Alejandro, for not handing over vehicle titles to at least seven of their customers. In a government move striving for consumer rights, the dealership stands accused of bypassing the state's Consumer Sales Practices Act and the Certificate of Motor Vehicles Act.

The lawsuit, etched in the legal books of Fairfield County Common Pleas Court, aims to steer the situation back onto the right lane. "Ohioans shouldn't get stuck in neutral when it comes to receiving titles to cars they rightfully own," Yost said, a statement obtained by the Ohio Attorney General's office. In response, Yost's Consumer Protection Section hasn't idled, releasing $19,236.27 from the Title Defect Recision (TDR) fund to give a little gas to those left in the lurch.

While the suit revs its engines for reimbursement of the TDR funds, it's also putting the pedal to the metal for additional money to cover unresolved complaints, along with civil penalties. Ensuring that no one is taken for a ride, Yost's office is also requesting that Rafael and Alejandro be prohibited from keeping or trying to apply for any auto-dealer licences or auto-sales licences in the future.

This court move by Yost signals a larger conversation about consumer protection, especially in the often murky waters of used car sales. The case is more than just about some missing paperwork; it's a stand for the rights of consumers to drive off not just with a new set of wheels, but with the peace of mind that comes with clear, legal ownership. Yost's actions echo that commitment to transparency and a fair deal – essentials for when Ohioans are cruising for their next car deal.