Columbus

Far West Side Tragedy: 11-Year-Old Girl Fatally Struck Crossing Hilliard‑Rome Road Near Sheetz

AI Assisted Icon
Published on May 18, 2026
Far West Side Tragedy: 11-Year-Old Girl Fatally Struck Crossing Hilliard‑Rome Road Near SheetzSource: Google Street View

A late-night crossing on one of Columbus’ far west side corridors ended in tragedy when an 11-year-old girl was hit by an SUV on Hilliard‑Rome Road, then rushed to Nationwide Children’s Hospital, where she later died, according to police.

Investigators say the crash happened around 11:58 p.m. on May 13, when the child tried to cross Hilliard‑Rome Road south of an intersection while the pedestrian signal displayed "Don’t Walk." She was struck by a 2015 Toyota Highlander, whose driver stayed at the scene, and was taken to Nationwide Children’s Hospital in critical condition, according to reporting from The Columbus Dispatch.

Columbus police later identified the girl as Scarlett Hightower. She died after receiving treatment at Nationwide Children’s Hospital, myFOX28 reported. No charges have been filed in the case, and detectives say the investigation is still active.

Hilliard‑Rome corridor has drawn safety work

The stretch of Hilliard‑Rome Road where the crash occurred has been a recurring focus for traffic signal and intersection projects. The Franklin County Engineer’s Office has issued public notices for signal and intersection work along Hilliard & Rome, highlighting ongoing concern about pedestrian safety in the area, according to the Franklin County Engineer's Office. Local officials and advocates have repeatedly pushed for safety upgrades on busy west-side arterials to reduce risks for people walking.

Police are asking anyone with video, information, or other tips to contact the Columbus Police Accident Investigation Unit at 614-645-4767 or Central Ohio Crime Stoppers at 614-461-TIPS, as reported by The Columbus Dispatch. Authorities say they are still gathering evidence as the investigation moves forward.