After city rejected Whole Foods for too little housing, new Polk Street grocery may have none at all

Local grocery Mollie Stone's plans to move into the long-vacant 1600 Jackson St. | Photo: Nathan Falstreau/Hoodline
By Carrie Sisto - Published on August 06, 2019.

As the Chronicle reported last month, local grocery chain Mollie Stone’s has announced plans to open its fourth San Francisco location in the former Lombardi Sports building on the corner of Polk and Jackson streets. 

The onetime sporting goods store has been vacant since 2014, though its parking garage continues to operate. For years, it was the nexus of controversy around a potential Whole Foods store, which was ultimately rejected by the Planning Commission because the company wasn't willing to build more than eight units of housing atop the store. 

But by allowing Mollie Stone’s to take Whole Foods’ place, it’s possible that the project will now move forward without the addition of any housing.

1600 Jackson Street would be Mollie Stone's 10th location, and its fourth in San Francisco. | Photo: Mollie Stone's/ Facebook

The new Polk Street store would be Mollie Stone’s 10th market, putting it just below the threshold of 11 locations to qualify as a chain store under city planning rules.

Once that threshold is reached, chains hoping to open in certain neighborhoods — including Polk Street — must seek conditional use approvals from the Planning Commission to move forward. That was the case for Whole Foods, which was subsequently rejected by Planning for its unwillingness to add additional housing units. 

But since Mollie Stone's isn't technically defined as a chain, it won't face the same requirements, according to SF Planning spokesperson Gina Simi. 

"While the Commission expressed support for some housing on this site the last time [during the consideration of Whole Foods], we saw a lot of community support for a local grocery store without the housing," Simi said. 

Image: SF Planning

In rejecting Whole Foods' application, the Planning Commission found that under city zoning, the 22,471-square-foot lot could contain a maximum of 56 residential units. By comparison, Whole Foods' proposed eight new units were considered insufficient. 

"Given the severe housing crisis facing the city, the [Whole Foods project proposal] does not balance the current needs of the city," the commission wrote in its December rejection of Whole Foods' conditional use permit application. "A mixed-use development, with maximum allowable residential density on a large development lot, could better serve the current needs of the city."

It's unclear whether Mollie Stone's, which got its start in Redwood City in 1986, will attempt to address Planning's request, or take advantage of the permitting loophole to skip out on constructing housing on the site.

SF Planning's Simi said that no formal application for the project has been filed as of yet, and Mollie Stone's founder Mike Stone did not respond to multiple requests for comment. 

However, in a press release, Stone promoted Mollie Stone's local roots, and notes that it "considers community involvement to be a key ingredient to ultimately satisfying valued customers."

Jan 16, 2021
San Francisco Castro

Castro Bank of America prohibits memorials from being affixed to the building [Updated]

Castro residents are up in arms after Bank of America (501 Castro St.) installed signs last week alerting residents and community members that posters, signs, and other materials could no longer be placed on the building — after decades during which the corner of the building at 18th and Castro has been a communal space for memorials to the recently deceased. Read More

Jan 15, 2021
San Francisco Castro

LA-based deli Heroic Italian opens pop-up in Castro with delicious sandwiches and salads

Los Angeles-based sandwich outfit Heroic Italian recently got its feet wet in the Bay Area, launching a pop-up in mid-December inside wine and spirits shop Swirl on Castro (572 Castro Street). With online ordering available, it's a quick and delicious lunch or dinner option — and if you pick it up yourself rather than opting for DoorDash delivery, you can snag a bottle of wine too. Read More

Jan 14, 2021
San Francisco Financial District Union Square

Marshalls store in the Financial District to close on January 30

SF’s only Marshalls location has its days numbered, as the discount apparel retailer will close its Market Street store. Read More

Jan 13, 2021
San Francisco Bayview Hunters Point Polk

Two new homeless Navigation Centers announced for Bayview and Polk Gulch

Supportive housing for more 115 people is coming to a Bayview parking lot, while 43 beds will be available at Post and Hyde Streets.] Read More