San Jose church fined $350,000 for holding large services in violation of health orders

Street view of Calvary Chapel San Jose
Google Maps
By Wesley Severson - Published on November 02, 2020.

A temporary restraining order filed by the Santa Clara County Friday morning orders Calvary Chapel San Jose to “stop ongoing and serious violations of the state and local public health orders,” as stated in a press release from the office of the District Attorney.

Santa Clara County called services at the church facility on Hillsdale Avenue over the past 5-months super-spreader events that have exceeded 600 people. The county claims people weren’t wearing masks or social distancing. 

Right now, only 100 people or less are allowed at county churches (25% capacity or 100 people, whichever is fewer), everyone must be distanced, and wear a mask. That’s why the county has issued $350,000 dollars in fines to Calvary Chapel. According to NBC Bay Area, county officials have tried to work with church officials to get them to come into compliance, and that fines have yet to be paid.

A Calvary San Jose Facebook post from July 7 of this year proudly depicted a group, none wearing masks. One follower of the Facebook page added, "The 'best' big group picture ever in over 5 months.I can actually see beautiful (faces.) Forget what our CA. Governor says! -- More MASK-LESS Face pictures, please? 🙂"

According to the Christian Post, this all started on May 31st, the day of Pentecost, in protest of Governor Gavin Newsom’s statewide restrictions on churches.

On Friday, Calvary Chapel’s Pastor Mike McClure along with lawyers for the church, and other pastors across the state came together at a press conference to speak out against the public health orders against churches. Robert Tyler, President of Advocates for Faith & Freedom which is legally representing the church, says that the orders are a violation of constitutional and religious rights.

Much as other churches around the country have claimed, the group claims the state and county are wrong when they describe the large church services as an unacceptable risk. The group said despite having large services over the past 5 months, not one church member has been infected with Covid-19 — but this has not been confirmed.

They also said the pastors at the church are being threatened with jail time for health violations but so far the county has not mentioned any warrants or criminal charges.

"To keep our residents safe, and to allow schools, churches, and businesses to reopen and stay open, we need everyone to do their part," Santa Clara County Counsel James R. Williams said in a statement. “We cannot allow any organization in our community to willfully and repeatedly violate these orders, while everyone else, including other churches and religious organizations in the County, are complying.”

The two sides were scheduled to meet in court today, Monday, to discuss the matter further. We will keep you posted.

Jun 11, 2021
San Jose

Bay Area day trips: Summertime in Monterey County

Discover beaches, biking, wildlife viewing, scenic drives and seafood feasts in Monterey County with Hoodline's Bay Area Day Trips. Read More

Jun 11, 2021
San Jose

Pride events happening around San Jose, including Newark Pride tonight

Various South Bay spots are hosting in-person Pride events this month, as well as virtual ones. Hoodline has put together a partial listing of some of the big ones happening around the area. And stay tuned for Silicon Valley Pride, coming up at the end of August! Read More

Jun 11, 2021
San Jose

Coworker feared VTA shooter could "go postal"; Feds questioned him about hatred of VTA

The Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority had investigated or disciplined mass shooter Samuel Cassidy four times before he opened fire on coworkers in May. Read More

Jun 10, 2021
San Jose

As drought deepens, Valley Water imposes 15% water cutback

As California heads into the height of summer during one of the state's driest years in history, the water provider in the Bay Area's largest county has declared a water-shortage emergency. Read More