San Antonio Residents Challenge Spiraling HOA Fees Amid Community Budget Battles

San Antonio Residents Challenge Spiraling HOA Fees Amid Community Budget BattlesSource: Unsplash/ Tierra Mallorca
Javi Gonzalez
Published on December 08, 2023

San Antonio homeowners are currently battling against a surge in homeowners association (HOA) fees, reflecting a nationwide trend where residential communities see costs incrementally climbing. The News 4 I-Team illuminated the frustrations of residents like Mary Ann Mathis, who faced a 10% hike in her annual HOA dues, a move she found exorbitant especially given the lackluster maintenance of community amenities. Mathis expressed her concern to News 4, saying, "I did not get informed by the dues increase. All i got was a bill in the mail." Mathis and her neighbors are probing their HOA bylaws, which she discovered should restrict fee increases to 5% per year, though Mathis claims her attempts to engage with the board were ignored.

Yet, HOAs often appear to have legitimate reasons to raise fees, as reported by the Cedar Management Group. The organization suggests that an HOA has the authority to raise fees to meet operational expenditures or to achieve adequate reserve funds, which are essential for the community’s long-term capital repairs and unforeseen expenses. The Cedar Management Group article states that "As prices go up, so do dues." However, HOAs must also be vigilant about adhering to their own governing documents and state laws, which often provide frameworks and limits for such increases.

Legal counsel and property rights specialist Patrick Sutton advises homeowners to "check your HOA bylaws and covenants carefully." This advice comes as a crucial first step for homeowners to understand their rights and any restrictions that may be in place regarding fee increases. Moreover, Texas law mandates that HOAs must notify residents before board meetings that determine hikes in fees, ensuring transparency and homeowner participation in vital financial decisions.

HOAs holding the purse strings are often caught between the necessity to maintain community standards and the displeasure of residents facing fee increases. Yet, they're urged to transparently communicate the rationale behind fee increases so homeowners like Mathis can better appreciate the costs that ensure their community remains a desirable place to live. Explaining such details can go a long way in easing tensions, reinforcing Mathis' stance that she and her neighbors "are going to get justice," as she resolved in her comments to News 4.

Ultimately, whether due to inflation, enhanced services, or bolstering reserve funds, HOA fee hikes tend to be an inevitable side effect of fiscal management in residential communities. The ongoing dialogue between homeowners and association boards will doubtlessly continue as communities navigate the complexities of financial stewardship in a climate where both costs and expectations are likely to naturally rise.