Honolulu/ Crime & Emergencies
AI Assisted Icon
Published on July 29, 2024
Breakthrough in 1991 Dana Ireland Murder as DNA Identifies Hawaii Island Resident Decades LaterSource: Unsplash/ Tingey Injury Law Firm

After more than three decades since the tragic murder of Dana Ireland on Christmas Eve of 1991, a breakthrough in the case finally surfaced, as DNA evidence has pinpointed an individual who was a Hawaii Island resident. According to Hawaii News Now, the suspect, a 57-year-old man who lived in Hawaiian Paradise Park, was 25 years old at the time of the crime and resided roughly two miles from where Ireland's battered body was found. The case, which has haunted the state for decades, saw a new light after recent advancements in forensic genealogy.

The identified suspect, whose name has yet to be released, took his own life last week after the execution of a search warrant for a cheek swab. This turn of events followed a period where the FBI and Hawaii County police officers initiated to closely surveil the suspect. Information obtained by Hawaii News Now detailed that officers managed to retrieve a fork the man had used and discarded. Testing on the fork matched DNA evidence found at the crime scene.

Ireland's case was especially heartbreaking, as she suffered kidnapping, sexual assault, and blunt force trauma leading to her death from blood loss. The Hawaii Innocence Project, along with law enforcement, used services from Indago Solutions whose DNA analysis helped pave the way in identifying the suspect posthumously. According to KHON2, DNA samples, including semen from the victim's body and sweat and skin from a t-shirt found at the scene, were tested and provided significant leads toward identifying the man responsible.

The implications of this DNA revelation are profound, not only because a suspect has been identified, but also due to the wrongful convictions it highlighted. Three men were previously charged with Ireland's murder, with two of them, Albert Ian and Shawn Schweitzer, having their convictions vacated within the past year. The third, Frank Pauline, died in prison. "He didn't spend a day in jail," Ken Lawson of the Hawaii Innocence Project expressed to Hawaii News Now, referencing the now-deceased suspect and lamenting the miscarriage of justice that had individuals wrongfully imprisoned. A hearing is scheduled for tomorrow to delve further into the new developments of this enduring case.