Calhoun County in Michigan faced an election issue this week as thousands of votes were incorrectly reported, potentially impacting the outcome of an important state House race. In what Calhoun County Clerk Kimberly Hinkley described as a "temporary issue," around 2,800 ballots within the City of Battle Creek were found to be overridden and not initially counted. Hinkley was confident, however, stating, "I am confident in the integrity of our election process, despite this temporary issue," in a statement obtained by News Channel 3. The omitted votes came to light during the routine canvassing process, which serves to check and verify the election results.
According to a report by News Channel 3, the unidentified error affected the 44th District where incumbent Democrat Jim Haadsma and Republican Steve Frisbie were vying for the state representative seat. Initially, the Associated Press had called the race in favor of Frisbie. Following the discovery of the error, the candidates' standings in the race grew much closer, with the margin reportedly narrowing to just 58 votes, further underscoring the importance of ensuring each vote is accounted for accurately.
Chris Trebilcock, an attorney for Haadsma's campaign, was quick to emphasize the importance of accuracy and legality in the election process. "This is why our election system has checks and balances. These inadvertent errors are designed to be corrected by the county canvass," Trebilcock said, as stated in an interview with MLive.
Meanwhile, the opposing candidate, Frisbie, expressed satisfaction with the transparency and security of the election process, despite the hiccup. Frisbie confidently told News Channel 3 that "he's satisfied it was a clean and accurate election, and that the ballots were secure the whole time."
The Michigan Department of State, through Chief Communications Officer Angela Benander, acknowledged the cause of this mishap to be a programming error. Specifically, two high-speed absentee ballot tabulators in the city of Battle Creek had their drives incorrectly combined, which led to this significant oversight. "It is typical during the canvassing process to identify these kinds of issues and correct them," Benander explained, in a report by News Channel 3. To address the situation, election officials in Calhoun County have began working alongside the Michigan Bureau of Elections with the intention to rapidly and transparently rectify the count.
Meanwhile, the Calhoun County website has pledged to continually update the public until votes are finalized, aiming to maintain public trust in the validity and reliability of the election process. As it stands, the outcome of the race between Haadsma and Frisbie remains unresolved, with both the Democratic and Republican campaigns monitoring the situation closely. The issue has broad implications as the control of the state House was tipped towards the Republicans in this election, with the party relying on seats like the 44th District to cement their majority in the chamber.