Cincinnati

Two Plead Guilty in Destructive Fire on Cincinnati's Big Mac Bridge, Stiles Faces 9-13 Years, Stumpf to be Sentenced in June

AI Assisted Icon
Published on May 28, 2025
Two Plead Guilty in Destructive Fire on Cincinnati's Big Mac Bridge, Stiles Faces 9-13 Years, Stumpf to be Sentenced in JuneSource: Cincinnati Fire & EMS

Two of four individuals charged in relation to the November blaze that wreaked havoc on the Daniel Carter Beard Bridge, also known as the Big Mac Bridge, and snarled traffic on Interstate 471 for months, entered guilty pleas. According to Local12, Zachary Stumpf and Terry Stiles, both were facing aggravated arson charges.

In a recent court proceeding, Local 12 reports that Terry Stiles admitted to one count of aggravated arson and another of arson. Subsequently, a plea deal was negotiated setting his prison term at 9 to 13 and a half years, additionally mandating his registration as an arson offender. On the other hand, Zachary Stumpf's guilty plea to obstruction of justice will lead to his sentencing on June 26, as noted by FOX19. Meanwhile, two other suspects, James Hamilton and Kaitlen Hall, are accused of obstruction of justice for allegedly trying to assist Stumpf and Stiles.

The economic toll of the fire on local infrastructure was substantial, with estimates placing the cost at over $13 million. According to a report by Cincinnati.com, the Ohio Department of Transportation suffered $11.5 million in damages, while the Cincinnati Parks Department incurred an additional $2 million in losses due to the fire. Amid these staggering figures, the full impact on the city's transport and economy is still being calculated.

Expressing remorse for the act that led to months of transportation disruptions and significant financial strain, Stiles was quoted as saying, "I apologize to everyone," during his court appearance as reported by Cincinnati.com. "It was a very stupid decision and I'm hoping you guys can forgive me."