New York City

Trump Administration Refers NY Mascot Ban to DOJ, Escalates Massapequa School District Controversy

AI Assisted Icon
Published on June 18, 2025
Trump Administration Refers NY Mascot Ban to DOJ, Escalates Massapequa School District ControversySource: Wikipedia/Glittering Pillars, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Trump administration stepped into the ongoing controversy regarding the Massapequa School District's Native American mascot, with the U.S. Department of Education referring the case to federal prosecutors. According to the Department of Education, the administration has accused both the New York Department of Education and the Board of Regents of violating federal anti-discrimination laws by enforcing a statewide ban on Indigenous-themed team names and logos, as reported by Gothamist.

Linda McMahon, the U.S. Secretary of Education, labeled the ban as "absurd" and insisted that New York rescind the mascot ban and issue a formal apology to tribes, highlighting the ban's alleged silencing effect on Native Americans' voices. Refusing an earlier proposal that would allow Massapequa to retain its "Chiefs" name and imagery, the probe's findings led to the referral to the Department of Justice, as laying out by McMahon's aggressive defense of the Massapequa School District's position. Reportedly, schools not complying with the New York state ban risk losing funding this summer, New York Post reported.

Contrarily, a spokesperson for the state education department, JP O’Hare, has denounced the investigation as "a farce from the outset," criticizing it as a mere political maneuver to support the Massapequa Board of Education, according to statements in a Gothamist article. The department claims to have most schools in NY, save for four seeking extensions, actively participating in processes to change their mascots away from Native American imagery and terms.

Amid this heated legal battle, significant expenses are predicted for schools that need to rebrand due to the ban. For example, the Connetquot school district has been vocal about the projected $23 million cost to transition away from the "Thunderbirds." Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman has welcomed the DOJ's involvement, praising Secretary McMahon for addressing the controversy, seeing it as an effort to preserve what he deems an integral part of American history, the New York Post adds.

Adding to the public discourse, President Trump earlier showed support for the Massapequa School District by voicing, "LONG LIVE THE MASSAPEQUA CHIEFS!" Massapequa's community and legal representatives remain defiant in the face of these legal challenges, with their attorney, Oliver Roberts, stating they are relying on support from various parties, which now includes the Department of Justice, as told to the New York Post.