New York City

ICE Arrests in New York City Soar by 56%, Targeting Broad Swath of Immigrants Regardless of Criminal History

AI Assisted Icon
Published on August 31, 2025
ICE Arrests in New York City Soar by 56%, Targeting Broad Swath of Immigrants Regardless of Criminal HistorySource: Wikipedia/U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Department of Homeland Security), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrests have surged in New York, surpassing last year's figures as federal enforcement intensifies. An analysis of new data shows that ICE agents arrested 3,300 immigrants in the New York City area starting from Jan. 20 to July 29, representing a 56% increase from the previous year, according to information obtained by Gothamist. This escalation reflects a larger national enforcement effort with a goal set by the Trump administration of 3,000 immigration arrests daily.

Highlighting the growing momentum of ICE operations in New York, WXXI News reported that arrests in July alone had exceeded the total number for the entire previous year. With increased activity, nationwide monthly immigration arrests have roughly tripled since President Trump's inauguration, marking a significant shift in ICE's strategy. The arrests are not just confined to individuals with a criminal history; data from the Deportation Data Project, as detailed by WXXI News, showed that 70% of those arrested had no criminal history, pointing to a broader net being cast by the enforcement agency.

Moreover, there is a noticeable rise in arrests of individuals with no criminal records. Data shows 57% of all immigrants arrested this year in the New York City area did not have a criminal history. Formerly, the local ICE field office had briefly shifted focus earlier this year, arresting more individuals with criminal convictions, but this approach has since changed. "Starting in mid-May, as ICE ramped up courthouse arrests, the share of arrestees with criminal convictions dropped sharply," Gothamist reported. The number of deportations has subsequently increased, with more than triple the amount of New York City area deportations compared to last year.

There is also a demographic shift among the detained. An increase in the arrests of older immigrants has occurred, and the average age of arrestees has gone up to 36, as compared to 29 last year. Adding to the complexity of the situation, ICE has faced criticism for its tactics, which includes agents wearing face coverings and nondescript clothing. "President Trump promised only to target the ‘worst of the worst,’ but ICE continues to target families, students and those contributing to society," Governor Kathy Hochul said in a statement obtained by WXXI News.

In response to these enforcement actions, community leaders have voiced concern about the broad targeting of immigrants, including individuals without serious legal issues. "We have seen people targeted that are not with any serious or legal, any criminality at all," Miguel Meléndez, president of Rochester’s City Council, told WXXI News. Reflecting these concerns, 26 Federal Plaza has been identified as a central site for such operations, with most of this year’s arrests in the city taking place at that location.