Milwaukee

Elkhorn Area School District Defends Associate Principal Against False Accusations Linked to Charlie Kirk's Death

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 15, 2025
Elkhorn Area School District Defends Associate Principal Against False Accusations Linked to Charlie Kirk's DeathSource: Google street View

The Elkhorn Area School District has been thrust into an unwanted spotlight amid a wave of misinformation concerning the death of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk. The district was forced to defend West Side Elementary School Associate Principal Cynthia Rehberg after she was wrongfully accused of making disparaging remarks on Facebook. The confusion originated from a since-deleted post by conservative influencer Ryan Fournier, who falsely claimed Rehberg "celebrated the death of Charlie Kirk's assassination". Superintendent Jason Tadlock had to step in to set the record straight stating, "She didn't do anything, she didn't do anything wrong," which was reported by WISN.

An unfortunate mix-up of identity appears to have fueled the false allegation. The actual post under scrutiny was crafted by an individual under the name "Cynthia Irene," which is neither Rehberg's middle nor maiden name. Tadlock's clarification came on the heels of over 560 voicemails pouring into the district's main line, many of which contained demands for Rehberg's dismissal, and hateful messages, as TMJ4 News reported.

The fallout from the erroneous association brought an unwelcome disruption to the school district. According to Tadlock, the district's tech team traced the original Facebook page to an individual located in Williams Bay, not an employee of the district. Efforts were made to inform the community swiftly, and the man responsible for linking Rehberg to the comments was asked to remove the post. As a precaution, law enforcement presence was requested at the end of Friday's school day, as detailed in the FOX6 report.

In a plea for rationality amidst the chaos, Tadlock urged families to seek information from official district channels and advised against jumping to conclusions based on viral posts. "I’ve seen social media cause things to speed out of control," Tadlock told TMJ4 News. "Don’t believe everything you see and read. Before we jump to conclusions or end someone’s career, be calm, be rational and look into it." His words seem to reflect a broader concern about the pervasive impact of misinformation in the digital age, where reputations, and in instances, lives are at stake.