Cincinnati

Butler County Man Indicted on New Charges for Stabbing Deputy and Arson Incident in Madison Township

AI Assisted Icon
Published on February 12, 2026
Butler County Man Indicted on New Charges for Stabbing Deputy and Arson Incident in Madison TownshipSource: Middltetown City Jail

A significant turn of events unfolded in Butler County, as Phillip Lovely, the man accused of a violent assault against a Sheriff's deputy, faces a series of new charges. These revelations follow after a grand jury returned a six-count indictment against Lovely on Wednesday.

The suspect, who was originally held on charges including attempted aggravated murder, felonious assault, and arson, has beens indicted to also include an additional count of felonious assault with a deadly weapon, one count of felonious assault causing serious physical harm, and two counts of inducing panic, as reported by FOX19. Lovely, 41, has been linked to a violence on February 5, involving a Butler County Sheriff’s deputy, during which Deputy Mike Farthing was answering a call regarding a vehicle fire at Lovely’s residence in Madison Township.

The situation escalated when Lovely allegedly attacked Deputy Farthing from behind with a butcher knife, as stated in the criminal complaint, which followed the intentional setting of his ex-girlfriend’s vehicle ablaze after their breakup. "Today is not your day," Lovely is reported to have said during the attack, as per the information obtained by FOX19. Fortunately, Farthing was able to report the stabbing over police radio and held Lovely at gunpoint until backup arrived.

Arriving on the scene, Deputy Drew Aspacher managed to swiftly take control, forcing the suspect to the ground. During the arrest, Lovely, who appeared to have been intoxicated, repeatedly asked the deputy, "Just shoot me," as recounted by Deputy Aspacher and mentioned in the report by FOX19. Following the incident, Deputy Farthing was urgently transported to Atrium Medical Center and thankfully, was able to be released the next day.

Phillip Lovely is currently detained at the Middletown City Jail, with a bond set at $125,000 cash. The additional indictments signify a broadening scope in the legal response to the attack on a law enforcement officer, as detailed across various local news reports, including coverage by Local12 and WLWT. These developments are being closely watched by local communities, reflecting a collective concern for safety and the well-being of law enforcement personnel.