A 15,670-square-foot Georgian estate tucked behind a gated drive in New Albany's ultra-private Illmington enclave has quietly landed on the market with a jaw-dropping $10 million asking price. The never-before-listed property spreads across roughly 13.7 acres, packing in six bedrooms, multiple formal entertaining spaces, and a five-car garage. In a region where seven figures already raise eyebrows, this one is built to turn heads. For buyers who want privacy, acreage, and classic architecture, it is about as rarefied as central Ohio gets.
According to the Columbus MLS copy reposted by Howard Hanna, the property is listed as 5000 Kitzmiller Road (MLS #226015216), showing 15,670 square feet, six bedrooms, and 10 total bathrooms on approximately 13.65 acres. The listing notes the home was built in 2002 and pegs the property's assessed taxes at about $65,305 for 2024. The MLS entry also designates the house as a gated, waterfront lot within the Illmington subdivision.
Inside the estate
Inside, the estate is pitched as richly appointed from top to bottom. A wood-paneled library wrapped in custom walnut millwork is anchored by a fireplace surround imported from England. There are separate formal living and dining rooms, along with a gourmet kitchen that opens into more relaxed family spaces. The lower level walks out to the grounds and is set up with media and office areas, while other amenities include an indoor pool, an elevator, and multiple fireplaces, according to the MLS marketing package reposted by Howard Hanna.
Neighborhood and market context
Set inside Illmington, a tiny gated enclave, the property is being promoted as a once-in-a-generation opportunity. Columbus Business First reports that the parcel is one of only a handful of properties in the subdivision and that it is being offered publicly for the first time. Aggregated New Albany data shows an average list price just over $1.1 million, underscoring how far this $10 million ask sits above the local norm, per Weichert.
Listing and logistics
The home is listed by Alan D. Hinson of New Albany Realty, Ltd., and appears on MLS feeds marked "Coming Soon" with an expected market date of May 4, 2026, according to MLS copies reposted by Howard Hanna. Prospective buyers and agents can request showings or additional information through the listing pages, where contact details for the listing agent are provided.
Photos and full property details are available on the MLS. The marketing materials lean heavily on the estate's size, craftsmanship, and seclusion, a combination that typically keeps trophy properties in central Ohio in steady demand. For the MLS record and full gallery, see Howard Hanna.
