Sacramento/ Parks & Nature

El Dorado Hills Neighbors Win Order Halting Oak Removal at East Ridge Village

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
El Dorado Hills Neighbors Win Order Halting Oak Removal at East Ridge Village1461 Blackstone Pkwy — Local Street Scene
Google Street View

A group of Blackstone-area residents in El Dorado Hills has persuaded a judge to temporarily halt further removal of mature native oaks at East Ridge Village, the sprawling new subdivision rising just south of Highway 50. The pause, granted through a temporary restraining order, gives the self-represented group more time to argue that the developer's tree-clearing work has gone further than what county planners approved.

Judge Extends Order Through Late November

Judge Extends Order Through Late November El Dorado County Superior Court Judge Hana Balfour granted the original temporary restraining order on Oct. 22 and set a motion hearing for Nov. 6, according to reporting by the Mountain Democrat. At that Nov. 6 hearing, Balfour extended the order and scheduled the next court date for Nov. 20, at 8:30 a.m. in Department 9 of the El Dorado County Superior Court in Cameron Park. Resident Jeff Russell, who is part of the group pressing the case, said the order gives residents two more weeks without tree removal until the next court date, per the outlet's reporting.

The order has limits. It does not prevent construction outside the disputed preservation area, and it does not prohibit emergency work immediately necessary to protect life or public safety, the same reporting notes. Bill Bunce, president of Valley View Improvement Co., based in El Dorado Hills, maintained his position after the Nov. 6 court date, according to the paper's account.

Residents Say Removal Plan Exceeds What County Approved

The resident group — which includes Russell, Julie Russell, James Stitt, Linda Stitt, Kenneth Hardy and Shirley Hardy — argues that Valley View Improvement Co.'s tree removal plan exceeds the protections baked into the county-approved project. Jeff Russell filed a civil complaint against El Dorado County, and the filing says the dispute centers on whether grading and oak removal at East Ridge Village Unit 8A departed from approved preservation designs and mitigation requirements without the required approvals and environmental review, the Mountain Democrat reports.

Russell has said oak removal would permanently change the existing oak woodland and viewshed in the area. He has also said that he and Blackstone neighbors alerted the county planning department to oak removal they observed over the spring and summer, and that county staff told residents changing the plan was part of the process, according to the outlet.

Central to the residents' argument is a 2014 oak protection plan that project approvals required the developer to follow. Petitioners received a letter dated July 3 from Ralph Osterling, the registered professional forester who authored the 2014 plan, stating that Unit 8A grading and oak removal conflict with project criteria and the plan itself, per the complaint. Jeff Russell also emailed Karen Garner, director of the county's planning and building department, that same day; per the complaint, Garner acknowledged the county had found that Unit 8A's permitted oak removal substantially conformed with the approved project. Garner did not respond to the Mountain Democrat's request for comment.

Bunce disputed the claim that tree removals violate county-approved native-oak protections, saying on Oct. 29 that development at the site, including tree removal, complies with county approvals and other regulatory requirements, the paper reports. The resident group has said it is not seeking to reopen the approved 2015 tentative subdivision map, nor is it seeking invalidation of the 2026 final map.

A Years-Long Project Now Nearing Construction

East Ridge Village sits on 734 acres east of Blackstone, south of Highway 50 off Latrobe Road, about two miles from the El Dorado Hills town center. It's billed as the second phase of the previously approved Valley View specific plan, following the completed Blackstone project as the first phase. The development includes 700 home lots ranging from a quarter-acre to more than an acre, and homebuilder Lennar is constructing homes there, with first occupancies expected in the first quarter of 2027.

The project's roots go back more than a decade. The Planning Commission approved the original tentative subdivision map, which provided for roughly 759 lots, on June 11, 2015, according to county project records published through Engage El Dorado. That map laid out 701 residential lots alongside landscape, roadway and recreational parcels, plus sites for a sewer lift station, water tank and pump station. The Board of Supervisors approved a development agreement for the project on July 25, 2023, and construction of required improvements began in early 2024, the same county materials show.

The El Dorado Irrigation District confirmed that water and wastewater capacity is available for the new unit, INEDC reported.

A Separate, Countywide Fight Over Oak Policy

A Separate, Countywide Fight Over Oak Policy The East Ridge Village dispute is unfolding against the backdrop of a broader legal fight over oak-tree policy in El Dorado County. The group Rural Communities United has filed its own legal challenge seeking to overturn the county's Oak Resources Management Plan and Oak Resources Conservation Ordinance updates, both unanimously approved by the Board of Supervisors on Oct. 24, according to the Mountain Democrat. That lawsuit alleges the county's adoption of changes to its General Plan's Biological Resources Policy Update, along with the oak management plan and ordinance, violates the California Environmental Quality Act. The lawsuit underscores how contentious oak-tree regulation has become across the county as development continues to expand into oak woodland.