
Whether a Harris County renter wins or loses an eviction case may depend less on the facts of the dispute than on which judge ends up hearing it — and landlords, not tenants, get to make that pick. A new study from Rice University's Kinder Institute examined more than 320,000 eviction cases filed across the county from 2019 to 2024 and found that rulings can vary widely depending on which of a precinct's two judges takes the case.
Harris County's Justice of the Peace precincts each have two courts, with each court led by its own elected judge, according to ABC13 Houston. When a landlord or property manager files an eviction suit, that party — not the tenant — chooses which of the precinct's two judges will hear it. Researchers found that within a single precinct, the two judges can post very different rates of rulings favoring landlords, rulings favoring tenants, or dismissals.
A Gap of More Than 12 Points
In some precincts, the difference between judges in how often they ruled in landlords' favor topped 12 percentage points, according to the same report. Rice researcher Steve Sherman said large differences also show up in sheer caseload — some judges within a precinct handle far more eviction filings than their counterpart sitting the next courtroom over. Researchers said they could not pinpoint exactly why those differences in outcomes exist.
That uncertainty is at the center of the fairness concern researchers raised: landlords can shop for a courtroom, while tenants have no comparable say in who decides their case. Sherman also noted that appealing an eviction ruling may work in a tenant's favor, though the report stops short of explaining what drives the disparities between judges in the first place.
A Push for Random Assignment
To address the gap, researchers recommended randomly assigning eviction cases between the two judges in each precinct rather than leaving the choice to the party filing suit.
Independent data point to how much is riding on these cases. Texas Housers reported that 76,321 eviction cases were filed against Harris County residents in 2024 alone — roughly one in 10 renter households in the county. The group also found the average number of eviction filings from 2022 to 2024 ran 30% higher than the average from 2010 to 2019, and that most 2024 cases ended in dismissal, usually because the plaintiff simply did not show up to the hearing.
One Precinct's Caseload Split in Two
Court-by-court numbers compiled by January Advisors illustrate how lopsided filings within a single precinct can get. In Precinct 1, Place 1's eviction caseload climbed from about 4,600 cases in 2022 to nearly 9,800 in 2024, while Place 2's caseload fell over the same stretch from roughly 6,300 to about 1,100, per the analysis from January Advisors. The report traces the split to early 2023, when Steve Duble took the Place 2 bench — after that point, the lines in filing volume between the two courts never crossed back. One landlord, Royal Phoenician, had sent 202 filings to Place 2 before 2023; afterward, it sent just 5% of its 201 filings there, the analysis found.
The median Harris County eviction case in 2024 took 24 days from filing to judgment, according to Texas Housers, and the 30 properties with the most evictions accounted for nearly one in every 13 filings countywide that year. Separate Kinder Institute Urban Edge research found more than 68,000 Harris County eviction cases received some kind of judgment over a 12-month period it analyzed, and that since the start of 2020, the county has logged 225,994 eviction filings — with only 2.02% of defendants represented by an attorney.
What the Law Requires Before Filing
Under rules published by the Harris County Justice of the Peace Courts, an eviction suit must be filed in the Justice Court for the precinct where the rental property sits. Landlords generally must give tenants at least three days' written notice to vacate before filing, unless the lease sets a different notice period. A landlord can also tack on a claim for unpaid rent in the same suit, as long as the amount owed is no more than $20,000 — or $10,000 for cases filed before September 2020.









