New York City/ Politics & Govt

Queens DA Melinda Katz Sues to Kill State Watchdog Probing Wrongful Convictions

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Queens DA Melinda Katz Sues to Kill State Watchdog Probing Wrongful ConvictionsSource: Christopher Matthew Thiemann / Wikimedia Commons

The dispute centers on whether New York’s Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct can investigate former prosecutors and obtain sealed case files. Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz filed a lawsuit on November 6, unsealed Monday, asking a judge to block the commission from accessing Queens case files, quash its subpoenas and declare the commission unconstitutional. The suit followed subpoenas seeking files connected to one of the borough’s most prominent wrongful-conviction cases.

A Legal Fight Over Subpoenas and Sealed Files

The Queens Daily Eagle, which reported the filing, said Katz’s office is represented by Greenberg Traurig. The suit argues that the 2021 law establishing the commission authorizes investigations only of prosecutors who remain in office and does not allow the commission to compel the DA’s office to unseal private case files. It also contends that the commission intrudes on the Appellate Division’s exclusive jurisdiction over attorney discipline, according to the Queens Daily Eagle.

The commission has not filed a court response to the lawsuit. Before the suit was filed, however, the commission disputed several anticipated arguments in an October 15 letter, the Eagle reported. Attorney Ross Firsenbaum wrote that the commission could investigate prosecutors regardless of whether they remained employed and would not withdraw its subpoenas because it had jurisdiction over former prosecutors. Queens DA’s office spokesperson Brendan Brosh declined to comment on the lawsuit, referring the Eagle to state law requiring commission proceedings to remain confidential until at least a conclusion is reached.

The Case Behind the Subpoenas

The subpoenas concern the case of George Bell, Rohan Bolt and Gary Johnson, who spent nearly three quarters of a century combined in prison for a 1996 double murder they did not commit, according to the Eagle. The victims were an off-duty police officer and a check-cashing business owner in Astoria. The killings prompted then-Mayor Rudy Giuliani to order a citywide manhunt, and then-Queens DA Richard Brown sought the death penalty for Bell, the outlet reported.

On March 5, 2021, Queens Justice Joseph Zayas vacated the three men's convictions after finding that former prosecutor Charles Testagrossa had concealed exculpatory material, including handwritten notes and police reports implicating other suspects, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. The New York Times reported that prosecutors never turned over police reports showing investigators had linked the killings to other men who were members of a local robbery ring. An NYPD officer's written interview note suggested that members of the Speedstick gang had committed the robbery, and prosecutors withheld that note from the defense attorneys, per the Eagle.

Katz created the Queens DA's Conviction Integrity Unit shortly after taking office in 2020, and that unit filed the motion to overturn the three men's convictions in 2021, the Eagle reported. The DA's office itself acknowledged, in joining that motion, that evidence had not been turned over, according to Gothamist. Zayas found that former assistant district attorneys Brad Leventhal and Testagrossa deliberately withheld exculpatory evidence, per the Eagle's account. Leventhal resigned as head of the Queens DA's homicide bureau and as an adjunct professor at St. John's University Law School, while Testagrossa resigned as Nassau County's chief of investigations less than a week after the convictions were overturned, the outlet reported.

Multimillion-Dollar Payouts and a Dismissed Complaint

The fallout has been enormous and costly. Bell received $17.5 million from New York City in 2023, which was the largest wrongful-conviction settlement payout in the city's history at the time, according to the Eagle. Johnson and Bolt each received around $15 million in 2024, the outlet reported. Despite the settlements, the Queens DA's office has continued to deny that its prosecutors behaved improperly, per the Eagle's reporting.

On July 14, the Grievance Committee for the Tenth Judicial District dismissed a complaint against Leventhal and Testagrossa, ruling there was insufficient evidence the two had violated attorney-conduct rules, the Eagle reported. That same July 14 letter stated there was “insufficient evidence” the prosecutors had violated the “rules and laws governing attorney conduct,” and the committee closed complaints against seven prosecutors in total, per Gothamist. The commission sent subpoenas to the Queens DA's office over the summer, according to the Eagle. Those subpoenas sought case files on Bell, Bolt and Johnson as well as records tied to two related cases, including a 2019 wrongful conviction that the Eagle reported first revealed evidence the three men were not responsible for the double murder.

A Law Professor on the Grievance Process

CUNY law professor Steve Zeidman commented to the Eagle on the grievance-committee process. Katz is up for reelection next year.

Katz's office previously told the Eagle it interviewed more than 60 fact witnesses during its own investigation of the Bell, Bolt and Johnson case, according to a statement posted by the Queens County District Attorney's Office.

A Watchdog With a Turbulent History

The Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct has had a rocky existence since state lawmakers first created it in 2018. The District Attorneys Association of New York sued over the commission, citing constitutional concerns, per the Eagle. Then-Governor Andrew Cuomo approved the first version before lawmakers later passed a revised version, the outlet reported.

A judge ruled the commission unconstitutional in 2020. In that ruling, Acting Albany Supreme Court Justice David A. Weinstein found the original law had created a parallel body with authority to find professional-rule violations and impose censure, taking issue with the appellate review process and lawmakers' attempt to “cobble together” a new kind of tribunal, according to Law360.

Lawmakers relaunched the commission in 2021, according to the Eagle. The commission remained unstaffed for years after that relaunch and began work after enough commissioners were appointed, the outlet reported.

Hundreds of Complaints, Few Results

Since becoming operational, the commission has received hundreds of complaints against prosecutors across the state, including at least two dozen involving former Queens prosecutors, per the Eagle. The commission has received complaints against prosecutors, the outlet reported. Gothamist also reported that advocates have submitted complaints involving several prosecutors.

Citywide costs and Queens’ internal review

The Bell, Bolt and Johnson settlements were part of wider city costs for reversed convictions. The New York City Comptroller’s FY 2023 report says the City resolved 13 reversed-conviction matters that year, costing $81.3 million. In FY 2022, reversed-conviction settlements totaled $86.8 million, or 37 percent of NYPD payouts, according to the Comptroller’s report. These citywide figures provide context, not a finding about misconduct in any individual case.

The Queens County District Attorney’s Office describes its Conviction Integrity Unit as a division within the DA’s office that reports directly to the district attorney. That internal review structure is distinct from the state commission’s inquiry.

Despite that volume, the commission has issued findings and recommendations in only one case to date: a censure of former Monroe County District Attorney Sandra Doorley, who used her title as the county's top law enforcement officer in an attempt to get out of a speeding ticket, according to the Eagle and corroborated by Gothamist's reporting on the commission's single ruling. The commission is the only state body tasked solely with investigating prosecutors' conduct, the Eagle noted. Whether it survives Katz's legal challenge to continue that work in Queens remains to be seen, with no court response yet filed as of the lawsuit's unsealing.