24 years after devastating fire, Saint Paulus Lutheran Church to return to Gough & Eddy

Saint Paulus Lutheran Church in 1964, three decades before it was destroyed. | Image: San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library
By Carrie Sisto - Published on January 22, 2019.

Nearly 25 years after the historic Saint Paulus Lutheran Church burned to the ground, it's finally returning to the corner of Eddy and Gough streets, as part of a new development. 

Pastor Daniel Solberg, who currently leads the church out of a rental storefront on Polk Street, recently signed a contract with San Francisco-based developer Maracor to redevelop the long-vacant site. 

Maracor has purchased the land on which the church once stood for a residential development, with a promise to provide the church with its own deeded 10,000 -12,000 square foot commercial condominium on the ground floor.

It’s a venture intended to meet the needs of both the Saint Paulus congregation and the city of San Francisco, pastor Daniel Solberg said.

95 residential condominiums, 11 of them below-market-rate, will be constructed on the site as well. 

The cathedral being destroyed by fire. | Image: San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library

Constructed in 1892, the Gothic cathedral that formerly dominated the corner was destroyed in a 1995 fire. The five-alarm blaze displaced 100 people, many of whom resided in two apartment buildings and a women's shelter that were located on-site. 

Since then, Solberg told us, there have been several efforts to redevelop the site, including never-completed projects that would have combined a space for Saint Paulus with an Alzheimer's care center and workforce housing. But federal funding for the Alzheimer's project never came through, and the financial crisis bankrupted the workforce project's developer. 

Saint Paulus' congregation has moved from space to space for the past 24 years, awaiting a permanent home. After operating for more than a decade out of an old elementary school building across the street from its former site, the church moved to the Fillmore in 2007, and now operates at 1541 Polk St. 

As a 'church without walls,' the 152-year-old congregation has devoted itself to street ministry among the homeless and other marginalized populations. It intends to conduct similar work once it moves into its new building in mid-2020, Solberg said. 

Rendering of the proposed development at 950 Gough St. | Image: Handel Architects

In addition to the 95 residential units and a 10,000-square-foot sanctuary, community and administrative space for Saint Paulas, the new building will also have a courtyard and roof deck overlooking Jefferson Square Park, Solberg said.

A two-level, below-ground garage will offer 61 vehicle spaces and 109 bicycle spaces, said Brad Dickason, principle with Maracor.

An official groundbreaking ceremony for the new sanctuary, "Up From the Ashes We Rise," is planned for this Sunday, January 27 at 2 p.m. Mayor London Breed is among the dignitaries expected to attend, Solberg said.

About 17 hours ago
San Francisco Cow Hollow Presidio Heights

‘Purse Filled With Yogurt’ alert on Citizen app milks jokes in Cow Hollow

The culture of Cow Hollow may be under attack, or maybe some joker called the police for a pretty cheesy reason. Read More

Jan 16, 2021
San Francisco Castro

Castro Bank of America prohibits memorials from being affixed to the building [Updated]

Castro residents are up in arms after Bank of America (501 Castro St.) installed signs last week alerting residents and community members that posters, signs, and other materials could no longer be placed on the building — after decades during which the corner of the building at 18th and Castro has been a communal space for memorials to the recently deceased. Read More

Jan 15, 2021
San Francisco Castro

LA-based deli Heroic Italian opens pop-up in Castro with delicious sandwiches and salads

Los Angeles-based sandwich outfit Heroic Italian recently got its feet wet in the Bay Area, launching a pop-up in mid-December inside wine and spirits shop Swirl on Castro (572 Castro Street). With online ordering available, it's a quick and delicious lunch or dinner option — and if you pick it up yourself rather than opting for DoorDash delivery, you can snag a bottle of wine too. Read More

Jan 14, 2021
San Francisco Financial District Union Square

Marshalls store in the Financial District to close on January 30

SF’s only Marshalls location has its days numbered, as the discount apparel retailer will close its Market Street store. Read More