Looking to uncover all that Story Hill has to offer? Get to know this Milwaukee neighborhood by browsing its most popular local businesses, from an Italian eatery to a Brewers-focused sports bar.
Hoodline crunched the numbers to find the top places to visit in Story Hill, using both Yelp data and our own secret sauce to produce a ranked list of neighborhood businesses. Read on for the results.
1. Story Hill BKC
Topping the list is wine bar and New American spot Story Hill BKC. Located at 5100 W. Bluemound Road, it's the highest rated business in the neighborhood, boasting 4.5 stars out of 481 reviews on Yelp.
Weekday lunch and weekend brunch are served. The dinner menu offers smoked fish chowder and chicken meatballs. Larger plates include country pork ribs with yellow peas, sour cabbage, whipped potatoes and pork jus. Top it off with warm cherry upside-down cake or dark chocolate chiffon pie. (Check it out here.)
Yelper Mike L., who reviewed it on Jan. 13, wrote, "Story Hill BKC is one of my favorite brunch places. Their menu is very creative, with a wide selection of food and cocktail options. Their crepes are delicious and filling, but their most underrated dish is their shakshouka. I have tried homemade shakshouka cooked by an Israeli friend and also at a restaurant in Israel, and this one is just as good."
2. Barbiere's Italian Inn
Next up is Italian spot Barbiere's Italian Inn, which offers pizza and more, situated at 5844 W. Bluemound Road. With four stars out of 96 reviews on Yelp, it's proven to be a local favorite. It also has another location in South Milwaukee.
On the menu, you'll find the Snack, featuring two meatballs in sauce, served with homemade garlic bread and a small salad. Sandwiches and pizzas are also available. Entrees include Barbiere's meat lasagna and chicken cacciatore. You can also order party pans. (See more menu items here.)
Syd Q wrote, "Some of the best pizza I've had in the greater Milwaukee area. Fast and friendly service, the pizza crust was baked to perfection and the cheese was just chewy enough."
3. Kelly's Bleachers
Sports bar Kelly's Bleachers is another top choice. Yelpers give the business, located at 5218 W. Bluemound Road, four stars out of 73 reviews.
This spot has been serving Milwaukee for 35 years and holds beer pong tournaments regularly, as well as weekly trivia and music bingo. On the menu, you'll find your usual pub grub, like mac 'n' cheese bites and chips and salsa. You can also build your own burger, choosing cheese and toppings. (Check out the full menu and beer pong schedule here.)
Daniel L. said, "Okay, it's not a high class bar, but what Brewer bar is? But the bartenders are really nice, the food is just the kind of greasy you're looking for and everyone is there to have fun. Set your expectations realistically and you'll have an awesome time here."
4. Tavo's Signature Cuisine
Tavo's Signature Cuisine, a Latin American and Mexican spot, is another much-loved neighborhood go-to, with 4.5 stars out of 22 Yelp reviews. Head over to 5814 W. Bluemound Road to see for yourself.
The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch and dinner and the menu offers three different types of guacamole. All meals include rice and beans. Try the Pineapple Pastor Express, which is half a pineapple stuffed with pastor meat and served with tortillas. Soft drinks, a house margarita and beer are also available to complement your meal. (Check it out here.)
Yelper Andrew B. wrote, "Absolutely phenomenal food. One of the best Mexican restaurants I've been to in Wisconsin. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the owners are very attentive and invested in making sure your whole experience is great. Amazing little place!"
5. J&B's Blue Ribbon Bar and Grill
Last but not least, check out J&B's Blue Ribbon Bar and Grill, which has earned four stars out of 36 reviews on Yelp. You can find the sports bar, venues and event space and traditional American spot at 5230 W. Bluemound Road.
Brewers Game Day is big at this spot, which offers a game-day menu including a fish fry. Burgers, chicken sandwiches and wraps are also available, as well as your standard appetizers like chicken strips and wings. A free shuttle will take you to and from Miller Park. (Read more about it here.)
William R. wrote, "Love this place. Excellent pub fare, especially the burgers that are fresh with Nueske's bacon. Very good fish fry with great potato pancakes. Nice beer selection."
