San Diego/ Crime & Emergencies
AI Assisted Icon
Published on July 02, 2024
San Diego County Settles for $15 Million in Elisa Serna Wrongful Death Lawsuit, Sheriff's Department Under Federal OversightSource: Google Street View

In a significant outcome for a high-profile jail death case in San Diego County, a $15 million settlement has been reached with Elisa Serna's family, with the bulk of the payout, $14 million, falling to local taxpayers. In comparison, the Coast Correctional Medical group is slated to pay out $1 million, this settlement marked as one of the county's largest ever in a wrongful-death lawsuit, a development confirmed by the presiding federal judge and reported on by the San Diego Union-Tribune.

Sheriff Kelly Martinez, who came into office after the incident, has addressed the settlement, emphasizing the transformation in jail operations since 2019 and expressing relief to now have the opportunity to meet with the Serna family, according to a statement obtained by the sheriff's department. The settlement also includes an agreement that places the sheriff under U.S. government oversight for the next year. This key element was informed after the case put a glare on the Sheriff's Department practices, and the death of Elisa Serna, who died after clear signs of medical distress were ostensibly ignored by jail personnel.

Elisa Serna, a 24-year-old pregnant woman arrested back in 2019, died within days in sheriff's custody after deputies and medical staff failed to adhere to withdrawal protocols despite her symptoms and her admission to recent drug use. The video footage from the jail showed deputies and medical staff neglecting Serna in her last moments, highlighting systemic issues within the local jail system, issues which have now garnered costly repercussions for San Diego County, as pointed out in the coverage by the San Diego Union-Tribune.

Paloma Serna, Elisa's mother, remarked that the financial component of the settlement does not mitigate the loss of her daughter, stating, "The dollar amount doesn’t matter," and highlighting her continued commitment to advocating for reforms, as she told the San Diego Union-Tribune. The settlement mandates updates to vital sign check policies and "training on compassion" and incorporates San Diego's alarming jail mortality rate, a spotlighted issue with 75 deaths occurring since Serna's five years ago, as per sheriff's records. The county is contending with numerous lawsuits, potentially setting up millions more in payouts.

Despite this settlement, San Diego County taxpayers are potentially facing further financial burdens emanating from additional lawsuits related to jail deaths, revealing deep-rooted systemic issues that continue to haunt both the justice system and the public funds, a situation extensively reported by the San Diego Union-Tribune.