Milwaukee

Gary Day Arrested for Beaver Dam Teen's Abduction Amid Nationwide Search

AI Assisted Icon
Published on April 17, 2025
Gary Day Arrested for Beaver Dam Teen's Abduction Amid Nationwide SearchSource: Dodge County Jail

After months of searching and considerable public concern, Gary Day, the 40-year-old man connected with the disappearance of a pregnant teenager from Beaver Dam, Wisconsin, is now in custody. According to WISN, Day was extradited to Wisconsin yesterday to face allegations of child abduction and child enticement.

On April 2, a truck driver's keen observation at Love's Truck Stop in Sarpy County, Nebraska, led to Day's apprehension. The truck driver contacted 911 upon seeing Day with 17-year-old Sophia Franklin, and Deputies swiftly arrested him. Day faces additional warrants from Wisconsin and Arkansas and local charges, contributing to a minor's delinquency and false reporting, as noted by WISN.

The case, which initially triggered an AMBER alert, has received widespread media attention owing to the circumstances surrounding Sophia's disappearance and her pregnancy. As reported by WBAY, officials believe that Day, who is suspected to be the father of the teen's unborn child, first came into contact with the teenager online and later abducted her from her Beaver Dam home in February.

To simplify the legal process and ensure Day's swift extradition, the Sarpy County Attorney’s Office dismissed the misdemeanor local charges, and an Arkansas extradition complaint. Through this coordinated law enforcement effort, Day was booked into Dodge County Jail, as per a report by FOX6 Now. The teenager was fortunately reunited with her family, bringing a measure of closure to a case that has resonated deeply within the Beaver Dam community, and beyond.