Philadelphia

South Philadelphia Man Pleads Guilty to Selling Over $200K in Counterfeit Jason Kelce Memorabilia

AI Assisted Icon
Published on August 08, 2025
South Philadelphia Man Pleads Guilty to Selling Over $200K in Counterfeit Jason Kelce MemorabiliaSource: Wikipedia/All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In a recent court proceeding, Robert Capone, a South Philadelphia man, entered a guilty plea for his involvement in a counterfeit scheme involving sports memorabilia attributed to Jason Kelce, the esteemed former center for the Philadelphia Eagles. As reported by 6abc, Capone attempted to sell over $200,000 worth of fake Kelce autographs and memorabilia. His elaborate scheme was brought to light after suspicions were raised about the legitimacy of the items.

According to information obtained by The Inquirer, Capone, who is also the head of Overtime Productions, was charged with theft, forgery, and conspiracy. In an effort to sell the forged items, Capone deceived an employee at Beckett Authentication Services by falsely claiming the autographs to be genuine. By crashing a private event where Kelce made an appearance, authorities say Capone took photos to suggest he had been involved in organizing it.

Initially, two coconspirators, identified as LeeAnn Branco and Joseph Parenti, were charged alongside Capone but were later cleared as new evidence surfaced. "Prosecutors had initially charged both of those people as coconspirators in the case, but withdrew the charges in June after finding they had been deceived by him and no part in his scheme," as per The Inquirer. Meanwhile, Alfred P. Sicoli, the artist whose forgeries sold by Capone, still faces his own legal troubles as his case remains pending.

The misdemeanors and felonies connected to Capone's fraudulent activity, as reported by Bleacher Report, include conspiracy to commit theft by deception, theft by deception, deceptive business practices, and forgery. Capone is due for sentencing on August 29, where victims' impact and restitution will be addressed following a pre-sentencing investigation. Despite his retirement after the 2023 season, Jason Kelce’s legacy as one of the NFL's top centers continues to hold strong with Eagles fans, many of whom were presumably targeted in this scheme.