Cleveland

Two Suspects Arrested for Aggravated Murder After Slavic Village Double Homicide, Cleveland Community Shaken

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 24, 2025
Two Suspects Arrested for Aggravated Murder After Slavic Village Double Homicide, Cleveland Community ShakenSource: Cuyahoga County Jail

Two suspects are now in custody after a manhunt concluded with an arrest in connection with a series of tragic events in Cleveland's Slavic Village neighborhood. According to cleveland.com, Andrew Dillon, age 33, and Richard Koballa, age 45, face charges of aggravated murder following two fatal shootings at the same residence on East 59th Street this past Saturday. The victims have been identified as Joseph Anthony Szymkowski III, 42, and Alissha Brown, 36.

The Slavic Village community was rattled by the violence that unfolded in quick succession this weekend, with Szymkowski suffering multiple gunshot wounds and pronounced dead at the scene around 2 a.m., followed by Brown's fatal shooting merely hours later at approximately 9:40 a.m. Koballa was eventually arrested after a standoff with police in Shaker Heights on Tuesday, an incident reported around 12:30 p.m. at the Kemper Court apartments, as stated by cleveland.com. He allegedly told a tenant at the apartment complex that he had recently killed someone in Cleveland, which prompted a call to 911.

In response to the quick succession of deadly events, Cleveland's Division of Police acted rapidly to restore a sense of safety among residents. "This case is horrifying and the violence in our community has been unacceptable," said Councilmember Rebecca Maurer in a statement provided to Cleveland 19. She expressed gratitude toward the police for their "swift work" in apprehending the suspects, an action which she hoped would allow the community to "rest a little easier this evening".

Further details regarding the motives and circumstances of the murders have not yet been disclosed. Both Dillon and Koballa remain in custody, with Dillon's bond set at $1 million as per cleveland.com. He is due back in court on October 6. Meanwhile, Shaker Heights Police had issued, then lifted a shelter-in-place advisory for the Kemper Road area during the manhunt for Koballa, as detailed by News 5 Cleveland