New York City

New York Nightmare Averted as "Commander Butcher" Pleads Guilty to New Year's Poison Candy Plot

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2025
New York Nightmare Averted as "Commander Butcher" Pleads Guilty to New Year's Poison Candy PlotSource: U.S. Department of Justice

Michail Chkhikvishvili, a Georgian national known as "Commander Butcher," has pleaded guilty in a plot that saw a potential attack against New York City's minority children. The 22-year-old, accused of leading the notorious neo-Nazi organization Maniac Murder Cult, admitted in Brooklyn federal court to heinous plans including distributing poisoned candy through an individual dressed as Santa Claus. According to the New York Post, Chkhikvishvili's guilty plea involves soliciting hate crimes against Jewish people and various racial minorities.

The initial indictment detailed Chkhikvishvili's plot to massively disrupt the New Year's Eve celebrations in New York, particularly with poisoned candy being handed to minority children. He also provided instructions on bomb-making and the creation of ricin, a deadly poison. During communications with what he believed to be an accomplice but was, in reality, an undercover FBI agent, Chkhikvishvili instructed the agent to also commit bombings and arson attacks. The plot was subsequently foiled by the FBI well before it could be acted upon, as reported by the Gothamist.

Not only recognized for this disrupted plot, but Chkhikvishvili also infamously disseminated his "Hater’s Handbook," which has seemingly inspired other racially charged violence, including a stabbing outside a mosque in Turkey and a school shooting in the U.S. These events were directly linked, by perpetrator admission, to Chkhikvishvili and his handbook, highlighting the global influence of his hatred. U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella Jr. condemned his actions as "monstrous plots and propaganda," sending a chilling reminder of the threat posed by radical hate groups like the Maniac Murder Cult.

Chkhikvishvili's guilty plea has paved the way for justice, with a sentencing that could result in up to 40 years in federal prison. The accused offered an apology to the communities he targeted in his heinous schemes. He would "like to apologize to those communities," he stated during his court appearance. Sentencing recommendations by prosecutors are said to favor a 14 to 17-year sentence, which will be decided in March, as reported by Gothamist