New York City

New York AG's Office Probes Death of Civilian Following Encounter with Off-Duty Monticello Police Officer

AI Assisted Icon
Published on December 06, 2025
New York AG's Office Probes Death of Civilian Following Encounter with Off-Duty Monticello Police OfficerSource: Unsplash/ Max Fleischmann

The New York Attorney General's Office of Special Investigation (OSI) has stepped in to examine the events leading to the death of a civilian in Sullivan County after an incident involving an off-duty Monticello Village Police Department officer. The encounter in question saw a man struck by a vehicle while crossing at the intersection of Pleasant Street and High Street in Monticello, as reported by the Attorney General's Office.

Details are sparse but, convey the tragedy that unfolded in the early hours of November 25, when at approximately 6:03 a.m., the individual was hit by the personal vehicle of the off-duty officer. The victim was subsequently taken to a local hospital where, after a few days of medical intervention, they succumbed to their injuries and were declared deceased on November 30. This incident has since prompted the OSI to initiate a rigorous inquiry to discern the circumstances under the New York State Executive Law Section 70-b, which mandates an assessment in cases where an officer's act or omission may have resulted in a civilian's death, regardless of said officer's duty status at the time of the occurrence.

An aspect of the OSI's mandate is particularly pertinent in such cases: it does not discriminate between the various states a person might be in when the incident occurs - armed or unarmed, in custody or walking free. The OSI will proceed with full investigations if their initial assessment indicates possible causation of death by an officer. 

The details of what happened that morning remain unclear, and the OSI has stated that the information released is preliminary and may change as the investigation continues. The incident is part of a broader focus on police conduct and accountability. The OSI investigation looks into the event and its impact on public service and community trust.

More information about this developing story can be found on the Attorney General's Office website.