Jacksonville-area Congressman Randy Fine has kicked off a nationwide uproar after an X post in which he wrote, "If they force us to choose, the choice between dogs and Muslims is not a difficult one." The remark, made in a back-and-forth about dogs, drew fast condemnation and resignation calls from across the political spectrum. Critics say it fits into a broader pattern of rhetoric they argue has increasingly targeted Muslims and pro‑Palestine activists.
What He Wrote and How It Started
Fine’s post came as a reply to a social media thread started by New York activist Nerdeen Kiswani about whether dogs should be indoor pets. As reported by First Coast News, Kiswani later described her original remark as satirical, but screenshots of the exchange spread quickly and put a spotlight on Fine’s framing of the "choice." The back-and-forth raced across X and other platforms, drawing in national politicians and pundits.
Bipartisan Blowback
California Governor Gavin Newsom publicly went after Fine, posting "Resign now, you racist slob" on X, while members of Congress from both parties pushed for either a formal reprimand or for Fine to step down. As reported by Newsweek, lawmakers including Rep. Yassamin Ansari and Rep. Brendan Boyle called the comment dehumanizing and said it should carry real consequences. Journalists and online activists also weighed in, warning that this kind of language can help fuel discrimination and hate.
Civil Rights Groups Turn Up the Heat
The Washington-based Council on American-Islamic Relations urged House leaders to condemn Fine’s post and pressed for his resignation, calling the remark dehumanizing and part of a troubling trend. DAWN reports that CAIR warned the post risks contributing to discrimination against American Muslims. The group’s statement added to a growing chorus of civic organizations and local leaders demanding accountability.
Fine’s Response and His Record
Fine did not back down. He responded on X, writing, "Islam is not a race, moron. It is a religion," and argued that the positions of some Muslim leaders on dogs justified his criticism. That response was documented by outlets including indy100. Observers have also pointed to his history of sharp remarks and legislative efforts aimed at Muslim organizations; reporting in The Jerusalem Post and congressional records detail Fine’s past statements and his role as the representative for Florida’s 6th Congressional District. His official profile on Congress.gov lists his seat and committee assignments.
What Happens Next
Calls for censure or resignation are likely to keep coming as civil rights groups and Democrats press their case, but formal discipline in Congress is not automatic and would require action from leadership or a vote. As Newsweek notes, House leaders had not announced any disciplinary moves as of Monday, setting the stage for a political fight in the days ahead. Back home, voters in northeast Florida will be watching to see whether the backlash reshapes Fine’s standing in Jacksonville or in Washington.
.jpg){kind=link}