A sweet local treat turned into a quiet safety scare when a Maui confection maker pulled a small batch of chocolate‑coated peanut‑butter‑and‑pretzel bars after peanuts were accidentally left off the allergen label, creating a risk for people with peanut allergies. The recall covers Tiki Bar Candy Dark Chocolatey Peanut Butter & Pretzel, a roughly 2‑ounce (57 g) package sold around the islands. Federal records show the Food and Drug Administration later tagged the action with a Class II risk level.
According to Newsweek, which reviewed FDA recall reports, the voluntary, firm‑initiated recall (H‑0523‑2026) involved about 300 units and flagged affected packages as those with a "BB 11/26" best‑by code or earlier. Newsweek reports the product UPC is 8 55725 00514 0 and lists the recalling firm as Taste of Maui Snacks, a dba of J2C Hawaii, LLC in Wailuku. The firm initiated the recall on Jan. 30, 2026, and the FDA assigned a center classification date of Feb. 24, 2026.
What Class II Means
The FDA defines a Class II recall as one where use of or exposure to the product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences, or where the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote. Per FDA guidance, Class II is a middle‑level designation used to help prioritize inspections and public notices.
Why Labeling Matters
Peanuts are one of the FDA’s major food allergens, and federal rules require manufacturers to declare such allergens either in the ingredient list or in a "Contains" statement right next to it. As the FDA explains, undeclared allergens are a leading cause of food recalls because even trace exposure can trigger severe reactions in sensitive people.
Where The Product Was Sold And What To Do
Local retail listings, such as HawaiiGifts, show Tiki Bar Candy among Hawaii‑made sweets, consistent with a limited island distribution pattern rather than a nationwide rollout.
Consumers who come across the product are advised to check both the UPC and best‑by code. Anyone with a peanut allergy should avoid eating it and follow the retailer’s or manufacturer’s instructions for return or disposal. If someone believes they have had an allergic reaction, they should seek medical care.
For general recall procedures and updates, see the FDA recalls page and check with the place where the item was purchased about specific return policies.
Newsweek says it contacted Taste of Maui Snacks for comment but did not receive an immediate response. This story will be updated if the firm issues public guidance or if the FDA posts further action.
