Sub lovers in Oconomowoc are about to get another option for lunch runs. Jersey Mike's is moving into Pabst Farms, locking in a storefront at 1350 Penny Lane and eyeing a spring debut as hiring ramps up and buildout plans move forward. The new shop will drop one more national quick-casual player into the growing retail cluster as the center keeps filling in, according to Greater Milwaukee Today.
Greater Milwaukee Today first reported that the sandwich chain is slated for Unit 105 at 1350 Penny Lane in the Pabst Farms retail center, in a March 12, 2026 story that flagged the new tenant and tied it to public notices listing the same suite number.
A separate job listing on Harri for a Manager in Training spells out the full street address as 1350 Penny Lane Unit 105 and notes the location is “expected to open in April 2026.” That detail backs up the spring opening chatter and suggests construction and staffing timelines are already well underway, giving curious locals the clearest hint yet of when subs might start rolling out the door.
Where the shop will sit
The planned Jersey Mike's will occupy part of a new multi-tenant retail building at Pabst Farms. City planning documents outline a master sign plan and tenant layout for 1350 Penny Lane that anticipates multiple storefronts sharing the address. Meeting materials from the City of Oconomowoc include discussion of signage and how prospective tenants will be arranged in the building.
Neighborhood context and nearby openings
Jersey Mike's has been steadily planting locations around the region. The chain already lists a nearby Delafield shop at 2910 Golf Road on Jersey Mike's, a sign of the brand's broader expansion pattern that makes Oconomowoc a logical next stop for franchise operators.
For now, the Harri employment posting and local permitting activity remain the most concrete public indicators of the timeline and scope for the Pabst Farms spot. Prospective hires and nosy neighbors alike can keep an eye on permit filings and the operator's hiring pages for updates. Expect to see exterior signage and more job listings pop up in the coming weeks as interior work and the tenant fit-out move ahead. Harri
