U.S. Marshals and local police are in an active manhunt for Benny Hurst, a 30-year-old man wanted on multiple drug-related charges across Wisconsin. Authorities say Hurst has skipped court dates on warrants from several counties and is believed to be hiding in Milwaukee or the nearby suburb of Brown Deer. The search follows two separate incidents that investigators say connected Hurst to large quantities of methamphetamine, heroin, and cocaine.
From Traffic Stop To Hotel Bust
According to FOX6 News Milwaukee, Hurst was first arrested in January 2025 after a traffic stop in Waukesha County, where officers say they found heroin, cocaine, and methamphetamine in the trunk of the vehicle. The U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force told FOX6 that months later, police in Ashland County stopped Hurst near a hotel and recovered about 67 grams of methamphetamine, 12 grams of heroin, and just over 6 grams of cocaine.
Investigators say Hurst bonded out after the first large-scale drug charge and was soon back dealing. He now has active warrants in Waukesha, Ashland, Ozaukee, and Dodge counties. FOX6 reports that Hurst is described as 6 feet, 1 inch tall and about 213 pounds.
Marshals Push For Peaceful Surrender
“It’s imperative that we bring Mr. Hurst into custody as soon as possible,” the U.S. Marshal on the case told FOX6 News Milwaukee. The marshal urged Hurst to turn himself in so that a peaceful resolution to the outstanding matters could begin. The information in FOX6's report was provided by the U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force.
How To Share Tips
Authorities ask anyone with information about Hurst's whereabouts to contact the Milwaukee tip line at (414) 297-3707. Callers can remain anonymous, according to the U.S. Marshals Service. The agency also offers guidance on submitting tips through its website.
For emergencies or immediate threats, officials say to call 911 so local police can respond to urgent safety situations.
What Neighbors Should Know
Marshals and local partners say the case highlights ongoing enforcement efforts against large-scale drug distribution in Wisconsin. They emphasize that anyone who thinks they have seen Hurst should not approach him and should instead contact the Marshals' tip line or local law enforcement.
The investigation remains active, and authorities say they will provide updates if and when Hurst is located.
