A 28-year-old Orange County man has been brought back to New York and charged in the killing of a Hudson Valley mother of two, a case that has shaken the village of Ellenville. Authorities say Michael David Carman is accused in the death of 29-year-old Nicole Izabella Perez, who was found inside her Clinton Avenue apartment during a welfare check in late March.
Tracked To Florida, Returned To Ulster County
According to Daily Voice, investigators followed leads to Clay County, Florida, where Carman was located and taken into custody as a fugitive from justice. He was extradited and brought back to New York on April 13, 2026, and is being held at the Ulster County Jail. Officials say he is scheduled for arraignment in Ulster County Court on Wednesday, April 15, 2026.
Victim Identified As Ellenville Mother Of Two
The victim was identified as 29-year-old Nicole Izabella Perez. As reported by the Times Union, Perez was discovered around 8:29 p.m. on March 31 during a welfare check at her Clinton Avenue residence. Ellenville Mayor Evan Trent told the outlet, "It's shocking," as the village struggles to process the loss.
Community Rallies Around Perez’s Children
A GoFundMe campaign was launched to support Perez’s two young daughters, and memorial services were held in the days following her death. The Daily Voice reports that neighbors, friends, and community members have come together to help the family as investigators continue to build their case.
Serious Charge, Severe Possible Penalties
Carman is charged with murder in the second degree under New York law. Murder in the second degree is typically prosecuted as a class A‑I felony and can carry decades behind bars, including life in prison in some cases, depending on the subsection and the outcome of the case. See FindLaw for an overview of the statute and potential penalties.
State Police Say Probe Is Still Active
New York State Police say the investigation remains active, with officers in New York and Florida continuing to coordinate on the case. The Times Union notes that officials have urged anyone with information that could assist the investigation to contact law enforcement.
