Phoenix’s famously quirky Mystery Castle is not headed for the wrecking ball after all. The hand-built 1930s landmark near South Mountain has a new owner who says the castle will be preserved, not demolished, and potentially reborn as a destination venue. The stone-and-salvage compound has been closed to visitors since 2022 after storm damage and vandalism left costly repairs unfinished, and the sale brings weeks of uncertainty to a close while setting the stage for a community forum on its future.
New owner, preservation pledge
The Arizona Preservation Foundation reports that the Mystery Castle Historical Foundation has sold the property to the Harrell Family of Companies, and that the buyer has committed to preserving the castle and adapting it for use as a destination event space, according to the Arizona Preservation Foundation. Neighbors and preservation advocates have welcomed the news, although they note that crucial details such as funding, construction timelines, and how much public access will be restored still have to be worked out.
Who bought it
Erick Harrell of the Harrell Family of Companies will lead the effort. His team brings hospitality and property experience, including projects under the Harrell Destinations banner, according to the company website. That background could shape a phased plan that starts with stabilizing the building, then layering in operations and revenue-generating events to keep the castle standing and open.
Why the castle matters
The Mystery Castle was built in the 1930s by Boyce Luther Gulley as an 18-room folk-art environment, and it has long drawn attention for its handmade materials and eccentric details. The National Trust for Historic Preservation placed the site on its 2025 list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places, a move that helped jump-start local fundraising and planning efforts, according to the National Trust for Historic Preservation.
Damage and a demolition warning
The property suffered major vandalism in March 2022, and city and police estimates put the damage in the low six figures. The castle later became the focus of a demolition-permit fight that included a one-year stay, which expired in late 2024, as reported by KJZZ. That period of uncertainty left preservation supporters scrambling to find a new owner or a funding model that could stabilize the structure before it slipped too far into disrepair.
Community forum and next steps
A community forum is scheduled for 2 to 4 p.m. Saturday, May 2, at the South Mountain Community Library, 7050 S. 24th St., where Erick Harrell is slated to share plans and take questions, according to the Arizona Preservation Foundation. Organizers say the meeting will focus on phased stabilization work, possibilities for future public access, and fundraising strategies, all before any construction or restoration officially begins.
How the city fits in
The City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office oversees demolition requests, public hearings, and incentive programs that could come into play if the new owner seeks permits or public support for the project. The office also administers small grants and technical assistance for threatened buildings, according to the City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office. Both preservationists and developers say that closing the funding gap, whether through grants, donations, or a viable operating plan, will be the critical next step in turning the new ownership into a long-term save.
.jpg){kind=link}