Sub lovers in Winter Garden may have a new reason to stroll downtown. Cosa Nostra Italian Deli, a popular Clermont sandwich shop, has filed plans to open a second location on Plant Street in downtown Winter Garden. Paperwork shows the prospective storefront at 32 W Plant Street, a notable expansion play for the family-run deli.
Plan paperwork points to 32 W Plant Street
Plan-review documents submitted under MDSL & DIAS LLC list Cosa Nostra as the prospective tenant for 32 W Plant St, according to Orlando Business Journal. The filings do not include a firm opening date or buildout timeline, which signals that the project is still moving through the permitting phase rather than ready for an immediate debut.
Menu and the Clermont origin
The deli currently operates its flagship at 798 W Montrose St in Clermont and bills itself as "an Italian family deli" on its website. Menu highlights such as the Super Tuscany and the Muffaletta Nostra appear on the shop's online menu and underscore a cured-meats-and-sandwich-focused concept, per the Cosa Nostra website.
Joining a busy Plant Street lineup
A Plant Street outpost would plug into a busy downtown dining strip that already includes The Attic Door, MoonCricket Grille, and Way Chocolate & Coffee, among others. Local coverage that tracked the plan review also points readers to the deli's social channels, and WhatNow notes the deli's Instagram handle as @cosanostra.italiandeli.
For now, city permitting records and the deli's social pages remain the places to watch for a formal announcement or opening timetable. Expect more concrete details once the owner or the city signs off on a confirmed date or lease specifics.
