Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier is turning up the heat on the organizers of the North American Irish Dance Championships in Orlando, warning that their policy allowing dancers to compete in categories that match their gender identity may run afoul of state law. In a formal letter, he demanded confirmation by June 30 that competitors who were assigned male at birth will not be permitted in women’s divisions, or he will consider legal action.
The championships, run by the Irish Dance Teachers’ Association of North America (IDTANA) and An Coimisiún Le Rincí Gaelacha (CLRG), are set for the first week of July at the Rosen Centre Hotel in Orlando. Uthmeier’s letter argues that state anti-discrimination and consumer-protection laws give his office the authority to step in.
Uthmeier’s Demand And The Countdown Clock
According to ClickOrlando, Uthmeier posted his letter on X on June 29, following a June 26 notice sent directly to CLRG and IDTANA. In that notice, he pressed the groups to confirm they would not “permit men to compete against women” in women’s categories.
Uthmeier wrote that “Florida law protects fair competition for actual women and girls” and warned that his office would take “appropriate action” if the organizers did not fall in line with his interpretation of state law. The warning comes on the heels of similar pressure earlier in June from U.S. Reps. Randy Fine and Greg Steube, who publicly called for the same rule changes.
Organizers’ Rules And Push For Inclusivity
On paper, the competition rules take a very different tack. IDTANA’s official syllabus features an Inclusivity Statement adopted in July 2022, declaring that the group is committed to preserving and promoting Irish dance “in an environment that is inclusive and free of discrimination and harassment,” as outlined in the IDTANA syllabus.
CLRG, the Dublin-based governing body, has also adopted a policy that allows transgender dancers to compete in categories that align with their gender identity, according to The Irish News. That inclusive approach is exactly what Uthmeier highlighted as problematic in his letter, demanding that the rules be revised before the Orlando meet kicks off.
How Florida Law Is Being Brought Into The Mix
Uthmeier’s letter leans on Florida’s Fairness in Women’s Sports provisions, codified at Section 1006.205 and described in guidance from the Florida Department of Education. Those rules govern who can play on public secondary and postsecondary school teams, and they distinguish girls’ and women’s teams based on sex assigned at birth.
The attorney general also points to the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act as another possible tool, arguing that private competitions could be challenged under consumer-protection law if they advertise women’s categories while allowing transgender competitors. That theory relies on language in the state’s consumer statutes in Florida Statutes, Chapter 501.
The Legal Gray Zone Around A Hotel Ballroom
Court battles have already tested pieces of Florida’s fairness law in school sports. A 2023 federal decision addressed how the statute operates in public-school settings, upholding key parts of the law in that context. What that ruling did not clearly settle is how, or whether, the same legal framework reaches a private international championship staged in a hotel ballroom.
Trying to stretch either that school-sports precedent or a consumer-protection theory to cover this Orlando event would be new legal territory. Any such move would likely trigger fresh litigation over whether the championship counts as a place of public accommodation under state law or is treated as a private contest with more leeway.
What It Means For Dancers Headed To Orlando
So far, the show is still on. The NAIDC site continues to list July 1 through 7 at the Rosen Centre Hotel, and the timetable and syllabus are still posted, indicating the meeting is proceeding as planned, according to the NAIDC website.
Uthmeier asked for a response by June 30. As of when news outlets checked in, organizers had not publicly confirmed any rule change, according to The Advocate. That leaves dancers, teachers, and families watching closely to see whether IDTANA or CLRG comply, push back, or get ready for a courtroom battle.
The next steps will help determine whether Florida treats private competitions much like public school sports for this issue or whether that question ends up in front of a judge. For now, the reels and jigs remain on the schedule while the legal music keeps speeding up.
.jpg){kind=link}