A security check at a vacant home for sale on the Key Peninsula turned up more than $100,000 in damage this week, after Pierce County sheriff's deputies spotted two 15-year-old boys leaving the area and detained them nearby. The teens now face charges of first-degree malicious mischief and first-degree burglary following the discovery.
Deputies Called Out Late at Night
According to FOX 13 Seattle, deputies were dispatched to the home along 191st Avenue Southwest after reports of suspicious activity. Per the Pierce County Sheriff's Office blotter, the call came in as a security check at 11:30 p.m. on August 26 in the 2100 block of 191st Avenue SW. A security check had been requested for the home, which sat vacant and for sale, making it an easy target.
While responding, deputies saw two 15-year-old boys leaving the area and detained them. The station's report notes the boys matched the description of suspects reported to law enforcement. Bodycam video reviewed by the outlet showed paint splattered on the floor, a water leak and destroyed appliances inside the home, which the Pierce County Sheriff's Office described as a deeply disturbing discovery.
Felony Charges and a Six-Figure Damage Estimate
Authorities estimated the total loss at more than $100,000, according to the same account. Under Washington law, First-Degree Malicious Mischief becomes a Class B felony once property damage exceeds $5,000, carrying up to 10 years in prison and a $20,000 fine, according to Milios Defense. The estimated losses at the Key Peninsula home far exceed that threshold.
The teens were also booked on first-degree burglary charges. Under Washington law, First-Degree Burglary is a Class A felony that can carry a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, while the lesser Residential Burglary charge is a Class B felony punishable by up to 10 years and a $20,000 fine, per Blair Kim Moeller, PLLC. Because both suspects are 15, their cases will move through Pierce County Juvenile Court rather than adult court, and they were booked into Remann Hall Juvenile Detention Center. Under county juvenile court procedures, youth booked into Remann Hall are held on probable cause, with formal charging decisions resting exclusively with the Pierce County Prosecuting Attorney's Office.
A Busy Week for Deputies on the Peninsula
The vandalism case was not an isolated incident. The Pierce County Sheriff's Office disclosed that during the same week, deputies also recovered two stolen motorcycles in the 13200 block of 99th Ave. NW, a stolen hot tub on August 22, and a stolen pickup truck on August 27, with the hot tub and truck found at the same property in the 7000 block of Cliff Ave. SW.
The cluster of property crimes lands amid ongoing concern over patrol coverage in rural Pierce County. Key Peninsula News reported that the county's 2024-2025 biennial budget funded just 0.57 sheriff's deputies per 1,000 residents, far below the national average of 2.4 per 1,000. During public hearings on the 2026-2027 budget last November, Key Peninsula residents submitted formal comments urging the county council to prioritize Sheriff's Department funding given the sparse law enforcement presence in the area, according to Pierce County. The peninsula is an unincorporated, mostly rural stretch of western Pierce County, separated from Tacoma by the Puget Sound and connected to the mainland primarily via State Route 302.
Remann Hall's Troubled Recent History
The teens' detention at Remann Hall comes as the facility remains under scrutiny. In a leadership shakeup this spring, longtime court administrator T.J. Bohl and probation manager Kevin Williams were abruptly separated from their positions at the facility. And in March, the Pierce County Council approved $750,000 in settlements for former detainees alleging historical abuse at Remann Hall, adding to more than 130 legal claims that generated roughly $7 million in county payouts in 2025.
Formal charges against the two teens have not yet been filed, and their cases remain in the hands of prosecutors reviewing the deputies' evidence. The vandalized home remains part of an active investigation as the Pierce County Sheriff's Office continues to document the extent of the damage.
-4.webp?w=160&h=400&fit=crop&crop=edges)
