New York City/ Crime & Emergencies

Harlem Man Indicted After Alleged Anti-Gay Deli Shooting, DA Says

AI Assisted Icon
Published on September 09, 2026
Harlem Man Indicted After Alleged Anti-Gay Deli Shooting, DA SaysSource: Google Street View

A 30-year-old Harlem man is facing an indictment after prosecutors say he was involved in an alleged anti-gay shooting near a deli. Theodore Tucker was arrested on August 8 in connection with the shooting near West 139th Street and Lenox Avenue.

According to Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg

The article links to Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg. Available reports describe an alleged anti-gay attack near a Harlem deli.

The available account does not include a statement from the district attorney or an acknowledgment of police work in the case.

An Associate Allegedly Blocked the Victim From Fleeing

An associate of Tucker's is accused of following the victim into the deli and telling him not to call for help, according to the indictment. That associate is accused of attempting to prevent the victim from contacting law enforcement or leaving the scene, and was separately charged in a Criminal Court complaint. The available account does not identify the associate by name or specify the exact charges filed against them.

The 23-year-old victim was reportedly shot; available reports do not detail his current condition or recovery status. The available sources do not specify Tucker's charges.

Steep Penalties Under New York's Hate Crimes Law

The case involves alleged hate-crime charges, but the available sources do not establish the applicable sentencing ranges or felony classifications.

The shooting site sits within the NYPD's 32nd Precinct, which counts the Lenox Avenue corridor between West 132nd and 139th Streets as its main business district, according to the New York City Police Department. The precinct's main stationhouse sits nearby at 250 West 135th Street. The precinct's 2025 totals for crimes, arrests and shooting incidents are not specified here.

The available account does not identify the investigators, prosecuting unit, prosecutors or analysts assigned to the case.

Part of a Broader Push Against Bias Crimes

The indictment is discussed in the article alongside broader hate-crime enforcement. The available sources do not verify the office's funding, the Jesse Diaz Ramos sentence or the cited hate-crime definition.

The available sources do not specify the Manhattan District Attorney's Office locations or the reporting hotlines for the DA's Hate Crimes Unit and the NYPD Hate Crimes Task Force.

Tucker is the subject of unresolved allegations. The available sources do not identify the other recent Manhattan incidents referenced here or provide a separate statement of Tucker's legal status.