
On Oct. 15, 2026, Eli Wasserman and Jeffrey Eisner married inside Masquerade, an off-Broadway production inspired by The Phantom of the Opera. Their ceremony and reception used two rooms in the immersive theater space, The New York Times reported.
The theater setting—and what it does not tell us
The production’s official website describes Masquerade as an immersive experience in a transformed historic venue, with candlelit chambers, staircases and hidden passageways.
Masquerade’s official FAQ says private experiences can be accommodated throughout the building and directs readers to inquire about bespoke events. That general policy does not identify which rooms were used for this wedding or explain how its arrangements were made. The Times reported that senior producer Cesar Hawas agreed to help make the event happen.
Other New York theaters also list event-rental options: the Hudson Theatre’s rental page offers spaces for private bookings, and Gramercy Theatre’s private-events page describes fixed and flexible reception space. These are examples of individual venues advertising event options, not evidence of a citywide trend or of how Masquerade’s wedding was organized.
A reunion after years apart
Wasserman and Eisner first matched on OkCupid in September 2013 and met a few days later at Carnegie Deli in Manhattan. Wasserman mailed Eisner a love letter shortly after their brief relationship ended in 2013. He found it saved on his computer in April 2025 and had received no response, according to the Times.
At the wedding, Rabbi Matt Green officiated. The couple’s first dance was to “Always,” a song Eisner’s grandmother often sang to him, the Times reported.









