
ABC's "20/20" put two Putnam County disappearances back on national television Friday night, more than 30 years after Robin Murphy and Josette Wright vanished.
Murphy was 17 and has never been found. Wright was 12; a hunter found her remains the following year, and the two men once convicted in her killing were later acquitted. Neither case has a conviction that still stands. People reported that the episode aired Nov. 13.
Two Girls, One County, No Closed File
Murphy was last seen on April 9, 1995, after meeting a friend at the Carmel shopping center where she worked at the ShopRite. Wright's mother reported her missing on Oct. 4, 1994. The cases are separate, and investigators have not publicly identified anyone responsible for either.
Murphy was described as 5-foot-9 and 140 pounds, with black hair and blue eyes. Investigators suspect foul play. No one has been arrested or charged in connection with her disappearance.
Wright's remains were found on Nov. 22, 1995, in woods near Fields Lane, according to the National Registry of Exonerations. Her killing remains unresolved.
What Turned Up Behind the ShopRite
Four days after Murphy disappeared, coworkers and friends searched the woods behind the ShopRite and found her work schedule and a paystub, ABC News reported. Her wallet and identification were later found near a dumpster behind the shopping center.
Those items established where she had been. They did not establish what happened after she was last seen. Carmel police renewed a public appeal for information in April 2025, on the 30th anniversary of her disappearance, and have said the investigation remains active.
Convictions That Did Not Hold
Anthony DiPippo and Andrew Krivak were arrested in July 1996 and charged with raping and murdering Wright. They were convicted in separate trials in 1997 and each sentenced to 25 years to life, Syracuse.com reported.
Before those trials, Dominic Neglia had already recanted, in a sworn affidavit, a statement implicating the two men, the National Registry of Exonerations reported. Investigators also found evidence suggesting Wright had been bound. A forensic pathologist testified that her injuries were consistent with asphyxiation, while her cause of death could not be definitively determined.
The convictions did not survive later proceedings. DiPippo was convicted again at a second trial in 2012 and acquitted at a third trial in 2016. Krivak was granted a new trial and acquitted in February 2023.
The financial aftermath is now part of the public record of the case. New York State paid DiPippo $2.9 million, and Putnam County agreed in 2020 to pay him $12 million. The county reached a $20 million settlement with Krivak in his wrongful-conviction lawsuit; he also reached a separate $5.72 million settlement with the state. Those payments followed acquittals. They did not identify who killed Wright.
A Man Looked At, and Not Charged
Howard Gombert has been investigated as a possible suspect in both cases. He has not been charged in either, and the allegations against him remain unproven.
He worked at a laundromat in the same Carmel shopping center where Murphy worked. Friends and coworkers said she knew him through his then-girlfriend. Gombert has acknowledged briefly meeting Murphy the night she disappeared and has said he last saw her walking toward the restaurant where her boyfriend worked. He denied knowing what happened to her, and denied involvement in her disappearance in an email to "20/20."
Other claims have circulated without producing a charge. A witness reportedly placed Wright in Gombert's vehicle on the day she disappeared. A former fellow inmate claimed Gombert admitted involvement in Wright's death. In 2000, investigators found underwear in Gombert's home that DNA testing linked to Murphy. None of that reporting establishes who is responsible.
Gombert, a convicted sex offender, is serving a sentence for third-degree assault after being sentenced in January 2002, according to reporting that cited the Connecticut Department of Correction. He is scheduled to be released by January 2027.
The Investigation That Is Still Open
Police have not closed either file. ABC News reported that a multiagency task force was recently formed to reinvestigate Murphy's disappearance. The Putnam County Sheriff's Office has said a task force that includes Carmel and Kent police and the state police is investigating both cases, The Highlands Current reported.
Carmel Police Chief Anthony Hoffmann told the Mahopac News, "We are following other leads and are continuing the investigation." The department has not identified those leads or announced findings.
Friday's broadcast widened the audience. It did not supply the missing person, or a conviction that explains Wright's death. Anyone with information is still being asked to contact Carmel police.









