
Justice Samuel Alito told a room of more than 1,000 conservative lawyers that Congress holds the power to shut down the Supreme Court entirely, simply by cutting off its money. Speaking at the Federalist Society's annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner, Alito framed the warning as a defense of judicial independence, which he said is essential to preserving the Constitution as originally adopted.
A Blunt Warning About the Power of the Purse
“Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities,” Alito said, according to The Hill. He went further, warning that abandoning judicial independence would fundamentally alter the country's founding framework: “If that is eliminated, then the Constitution as adopted in 1789 will no longer be the same.” The remarks were delivered at the dinner named for the late conservative justice, held as part of the Federalist Society's annual convention each November, as also reported by WRIC ABC 8News.
The timing drew attention because the convention took place one week after Democrats swept control of both houses of Congress, per the same Hill report. Yet Alito made no reference to the midterm elections or the pending change in power during his remarks, the outlet noted. KRQE separately observed that Democrats have eyed using Congress's spending power as leverage against the conservative-majority high court before.
'Least Powerful Branch,' Alito Says
Alito described the judiciary as the least powerful branch of government, calling it vulnerable to both Congress and the executive branch. That vulnerability, he argued, is precisely why judicial independence matters so much and why threats to defund the Court's operations carry real weight rather than being an abstract concern.
Alito also turned his attention to lower-court judges, criticizing some for issuing orders that blocked presidents' policies in recent years. He said lower judges are generally dedicated and skillful but imperfect and capable of making mistakes, adding that “in some instances, I think they have gone far astray in abuse of their powers.” His comments warned that judges can overstep the bounds of their authority.
Justices' Push for Judiciary Funding
Alito's remarks followed a rare, direct lobbying effort by two of his colleagues. Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett visited Capitol Hill over the summer to advocate for increasing the judiciary's budget and boosting security funding amid rising threat levels, according to the Hill report.
The Scalia dinner itself has become something of a recurring staple for sitting justices. Justice Brett Kavanaugh and Barrett shared the stage at last year's dinner, while Justices Neil Gorsuch and Stephen Breyer joined the event the year before that. Alito himself once addressed the dinner virtually during the pandemic, describing the health crisis at the time as having caused previously unimaginable restrictions on civil liberties.
The Federalist Society's Role
Though the Federalist Society does not officially take political or legal positions, it has over decades become an incubator for Republican judicial nominees and a tentpole of the conservative legal movement, the Hill reported. That institutional weight is part of why Alito's remarks, delivered to the group's faithful, carry particular resonance inside conservative legal circles.
On the underlying legal question, the Constitution Annotated, maintained by Congress.gov, notes that Congress has substantial authority to structure the Supreme Court but cannot abolish the high court outright. Alito's warning concerned funding, not abolition, and remains a conditional scenario rather than a step Congress has taken.









