
Elizabeth Adams declared victory in the Anne Arundel County Circuit Court race after finishing ahead of one sitting judge, while fellow candidate Sidney Butcher appeared to secure the other seat, a result the Daily Record described as an upset in Maryland's judicial politics, where challengers rarely defeat sitting judges. As of Monday afternoon, Adams led with over 36% of the vote, putting her more than 11,000 ballots ahead of fellow candidate Sidney Butcher.
Butcher appeared to secure one of the two contested Circuit Court seats, running on a slate with sitting judge Ginina Jackson-Stevenson for full 15-year terms, according to the Maryland Daily Record. Jackson-Stevenson appeared to finish third, receiving about 30% of the vote, or just over 100,000 votes. The race was a three-way contest for two seats, with the two top vote-getters winning full terms on the bench.
Anne Arundel County was still canvassing final mail-in ballots as of Monday, and county election official David Garreis told the Daily Record he expected results to be certified later that day. Adams, who said she stood watch as her campaign came to a landing, spent last Thursday at the county board of elections during its provisional ballot canvass.
A Self-Funded Challenger's Long Road
Adams, a 50-year-old attorney, had previously asked the local judicial nominating commission to recommend her for a judgeship but was not selected, according to The Banner. She graduated from the University of Baltimore School of Law in 1999 and went on to work as an assistant state's attorney in Anne Arundel before joining the county's law department. She also represented Maryland as an assistant attorney general for about six years and worked in the law departments for Howard and Prince George's counties, per the Daily Record's reporting.
Adams largely self-funded her bid, carrying $100,000 in outstanding campaign committee loans heading into Election Day. That spending came against the backdrop of what the Daily Record's October 30 report called one of Maryland's most expensive judicial contests, with the three candidates and the sitting judges' slate spending more than $300,000 on the race as of the October campaign finance reporting deadline. The Keep Our Judges 2026 slate tied to Jackson-Stevenson and Butcher had put in an additional $70,000 on top of that, the same report found.
How Maryland Fills — and Unseats — Its Judges
Maryland circuit court judges are usually seated first through gubernatorial appointment, after vetting by a committee and the local judicial nominating commission. But under the system, an appointed judge must then win election to secure a full 15-year term, with candidates running in both the Democratic and Republican primaries despite holding no formal party affiliation. Adams secured a Republican primary slot, Butcher secured slots in both party primaries, and Jackson-Stevenson secured a Democratic primary slot.
This is not the first time Jackson-Stevenson has faced defeat at the ballot box. Thomas Casey beat her in the 2024 election, and Gov. Wes Moore reappointed her to a different Circuit Court vacancy on the same bench about a month later, according to the Daily Record's prior reporting. That 2024 Anne Arundel contest was one of just two contested judicial elections statewide that year, per a Banner opinion column.
Challengers defeating sitting judges remains uncommon in Maryland. The Daily Record has characterized such wins as rare, and a separate Banner column noted that only 14 Maryland judges have lost elections since 1985, while a different Banner opinion piece put the number of challenger victories over the past 50 years at 17. A 2022 analysis from Maryland Matters found that eight of nine challenged circuit court incumbents whose results were certified that year won both the Democratic and Republican nominations — though that same report noted appointed incumbents had lost general elections in Prince George's, Charles and Howard counties back in 2020.
Adams Pushes Back on What She Says She Was Told
Adams framed her win as proof that predictions about the race, and about voter engagement in judicial contests generally, fell flat. “They told me we would not win, and if we did, it would be because of ballot position alone, and probably only by a few hundred votes,” she said. She added, “They told me that voters are uninformed about down-ballot and court house races,” before concluding, “They told me — and you — a lot of things that weren't true.”
In a social media post, Adams wrote, “Thank you, Anne Arundel! Because you took the time to care, your hometown girl is going to be a judge.” The remark capped a campaign that began with Adams trying — and failing — to win a judicial nomination through the traditional appointment process before deciding to take her case directly to voters.









