
Two girls who were 15 years old at the time say they were waiting for a Metro train at Pentagon City Mall when five Arlington County police officers and Metro security surrounded them, accused them of shoplifting, and handcuffed one of them after she wouldn't give up her age. A mall employee eventually told officers the girls weren't the ones who had actually stolen from Lululemon, and they were let go. Now the two teenagers, who are Black, are suing Arlington County police for $400,000 in damages.
According to a 13-page federal lawsuit filed last week, officers and Metro security approached the girls as they waited for their train and accused them of shoplifting from the Lululemon inside Fashion Centre at Pentagon City, as reported by NBC4 Washington. The suit alleges the encounter happened on Presidents Day of the previous year and claims officers handcuffed one of the girls when she wouldn't tell them her age. Attorneys say officers also took the teenagers' cellphones away when they tried to call their parents, and the lawsuit alleges the girls were grabbed by the arm and escorted outside the Metro faregates.
The station's report says a mall employee ultimately told police the girls were not the ones responsible for the theft at the store, and the teens were released. Madeleine Gates, who represents the girls through the Washington Lawyers' Committee, one of two law firms on the case, said the suspect description police were working from was vague: two short girls, one wearing a pink jacket. But Gates said one of the plaintiffs was wearing a pink coat and stood about 6 feet tall, a detail she says undercuts the match officers claimed to see.
Attorney Says Teens' Rights Were Violated
Gates said the Washington Lawyers' Committee filed the suit to seek justice for the teenagers, arguing the girls have the same Fourth Amendment rights as everyone else. She described the encounter as traumatic for the girls and their families, according to the same account relayed to NBC4. Gates also said Arlington County police would not share details about the underlying shoplifting investigation with her office because the case remained under investigation.
Per the outlet's reporting, Arlington County police, the mall's general manager, and Lululemon had not responded to requests for comment, while a Metro spokesperson declined to comment at this time.
Shoplifting Reports Have Surged Countywide
The lawsuit lands against a backdrop of rising retail theft complaints in Arlington. Shoplifting cases jumped by around 76%, from 1,060 in 2023 to 1,863 in 2024, according to ARLnow. Arlington property crimes overall rose roughly 12% in 2024, with larcenies and thefts driving much of that increase, the outlet reported. Police told ARLnow the increase likely reflects both more actual offenses and better reporting by businesses through an online system.
Pentagon City has become a focal point for retail-crime enforcement in response. In a May 30 operation there, Arlington County police arrested seven people on petit larceny charges and one person on a grand larceny charge, recovering more than $6,000 in stolen merchandise, per ARLnow's reporting. A later enforcement effort on Aug. 22 resulted in 15 suspects taken into custody, facing 15 felony and 30 misdemeanor charges combined, with thousands of dollars in merchandise recovered and 20 store-ban notices issued, according to a separate ARLnow report. That same account notes a previous retail-theft detail in the spring had already produced eight arrests in the area.









