
Auburn University's Board of Trustees was scheduled Friday to consider a new post-tenure review policy that would grade tenured faculty on a four-tier scale and give deans and the provost sweeping authority over outcomes, including dismissal in some cases without a formal improvement plan. The university's chapter of the American Association of University Professors said it unequivocally opposes the measure, calling it a fundamental restructuring of the relationship between the university and its faculty.
The proposed policy, as detailed by Alabama Reflector, would rate professors as exceeds expectations, meets expectations, does not meet expectations, or unsatisfactory. Reviews would happen at least once every six years, and no faculty member could be reviewed more than once in a given year. Under the process, a college dean would recommend an outcome to the provost, who may seek advice from a faculty advisory body or other peer review body before settling on a final rating, according to the same report. The university president would then exercise review, approval, or oversight of those determinations as spelled out in university procedures.
Faculty rated does not meet expectations would be referred to the provost to decide whether a Performance Improvement Plan is warranted. Tenured professors rated unsatisfactory, however, could be dismissed without ever being offered one, Alabama Reflector reported. Separately, 1819 News reported that the six-year review clock would start when a professor earns tenure or a promotion and would restart with each subsequent promotion, with an earlier review triggered if an annual evaluation rates a professor does not meet expectations or unsatisfactory in any area.
AAUP Says Policy Strips Away Protections
Auburn's AAUP chapter framed its objection in stark terms, according to Alabama Reflector's reporting: its statement characterized the policy as treating faculty as employees to be monitored and managed rather than as scholars entrusted with academic judgment. The same statement said the policy concentrates authority in administrators while diminishing faculty judgment and due process, the outlet reported.
That critique lands differently against the backdrop of Auburn's prior process. University materials describing the 2021 handbook revisions show that post-tenure review previously assessed a faculty member's quantity and quality of work over the preceding six years, with a trigger requiring a second overall unacceptable annual evaluation within a six-year period before review began. Those older provisions also allowed a faculty member to appeal a provost's decision in writing within ten working days of receiving it, and prescribed a 12-month development plan with specific, measurable goals when a faculty member's performance was judged unsatisfactory.
Faculty Senates Already Reshaped Statewide
The tenure fight follows a broader reordering of faculty governance across Alabama's public universities this year. Auburn's own governance page states that prior to June 5, 2026, the university operated under a University Senate model, and that academic advisory functions are now handled instead by the Presidential Academic Advisory Council, which the university describes as its primary forum for faculty consultation on academic matters.
Alabama Reflector's October reporting found that public universities around the state interpreted a new state law differently, with some moving to abolish their faculty senates over the summer while others committed to keeping them. Auburn and Jacksonville State University abolished their faculty senates amid protests from faculty groups, while the University of Alabama and Troy University voted to retain theirs, the outlet reported. Troy's Board of Trustees voted Monday to maintain its senate, according to the same Alabama Reflector report, while the University of Alabama's trustees voted to keep faculty senates on all of its campuses but limited them to an advisory role, per Inside Higher Ed's coverage of the system's changes.
The University of Alabama System also established post-tenure review for all tenured faculty, setting reviews at least once every five years — a shorter interval than the six-year minimum Auburn has proposed, Inside Higher Ed reported. That system's executive committee did not dissolve its existing faculty senates when it made the advisory-only shift, the outlet noted.
Pushback Organizing Ahead of the Vote
Opposition to Auburn's proposal has also come from outside the AAUP chapter. United Campus Workers of Alabama, described in reporting as an organization working to improve higher education employees' working conditions, wages, and benefits, circulated a petition urging the university to maintain its current post-tenure review process; that petition exceeded its goal of 500 signatures, according to the reporting.
The policy debate traces back to state legislation signed by Gov. Kay Ivey in April, which authorized university trustee boards to disband faculty senates and cleared the way for the post-tenure review changes now before Auburn's board. An AL.com report from April noted that Auburn and the University of Alabama are technically exempt from that law because both were created within the Alabama Constitution, even as both institutions moved to revise their governance and review structures regardless.









