
Babylon has withdrawn proposed pay increases for its elected officials, including a 29.3% raise for Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer. But the change does not settle the central taxpayer question of how the proposed 2027 budget would affect taxes; the town’s past tax-cap decisions do not establish whether this budget would exceed the cap.
A salary reversal, with the budget still pending
The preliminary budget proposed raising Schaffer’s annual salary from $123,680 to $160,000, alongside a property-tax increase. Residents criticized the plan at a Nov. 12 public hearing. On Wednesday, Schaffer told Newsday he would not take the proposed raise.
The town also removed proposed increases for other elected officials. Schaffer said the changes would save $83,662 in the $218.3 million preliminary budget, Newsday reported. The Town Board was scheduled to vote on the budget Nov. 18, so the salary change alone does not establish what tax plan the board would adopt.
Past cap decisions offer context, not an answer for 2027
Babylon’s tax-cap history shows why each budget year needs to be considered separately. The town’s 2024 financial statements describe the levy limit as generally 2% or inflation, whichever is lower, with a permitted increase of at least 1%; they also say a local government may exceed the limit through a 60% governing-body vote or local law. The statements say Babylon elected to exceed the cap in 2025. (Town of Babylon 2024 financial statements.)
Other annual records show different outcomes: Babylon’s 2021 financial statements say the town elected to exceed the cap in 2022, while its 2025 statements say it did not exceed the cap in 2026. Those are decisions for separate budget years, not evidence of whether the proposed 2027 budget would exceed the limit. (2021 statements; 2025 statements.)
Tax figures for different years
Newsday reported a nearly 6% property-tax increase and an estimated $113 to $114 annual increase for an average homeowner outside village boundaries. News 12 Long Island, by contrast, reported a 9.9% tax-levy increase proposed for the 2025 budget and an estimated $173 more per year for the average household. The figures concern different budget years and measures, and neither alone determines whether the proposed 2027 levy would exceed the legal limit.
The salary proposal has changed, but the tax proposal and its final status remain for the board to resolve. The town’s past cap decisions provide useful background, not a substitute for the adopted 2027 budget or the records needed to determine how that budget compares with the levy limit.









