
The key question as Donell Trusty’s Baltimore trial began Tuesday is sharply contested: who fired first after a traffic dispute, and whether Trusty acted in self-defense. Trusty, 41, faces attempted first- and second-degree murder charges and related assault and firearm offenses over a May 13 shooting outside a gas station, Baltimore Witness reported.
The case began with a minor collision, according to the report: prosecutors said Trusty hit another vehicle’s side-view mirror while trying to drive around it on a rainy night. They allege that honking and yelling followed, and that Trusty fired into the other driver’s occupied vehicle before it had fully stopped. The other driver said Trusty shot at him; surveillance footage reportedly corroborated that account, the outlet reported. Those claims remain disputed at trial.
The evidence and accounts remain in conflict
Defense attorney Martin Cohen argued in opening statements that Trusty fired in self-defense. Cohen said the other driver followed Trusty, pulled out a gun and fired first, then threatened him. He also said Trusty drove to a gas station and called 911 on the way. These are the defense’s claims, not findings by the jury.
Cohen further said Trusty cooperated with police and told officers there was a semiautomatic handgun in the other driver’s center console. Police confirmed that a handgun was there, Baltimore Witness reported. Cohen criticized investigators for not gathering additional evidence, including possible Ring doorbell footage. The report said the trial, before Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Martin H. Schreiber III, was expected to resume Thursday.
Broader figures do not resolve this case
The dispute comes amid a documented rise in U.S. road-rage shooting incidents, but national counts cannot establish what happened in this encounter. HuffPost, reporting on Everytown for Gun Safety research using Gun Violence Archive data, counted 218 incidents in 2018 and 483 in 2023. Those figures describe a national trend, not the circumstances or evidence in Trusty’s case.
A separate Baltimore self-defense case illustrates why courtroom outcomes depend on the evidence and circumstances of each incident. Baltimore Witness reported that Judge Jeffrey M. Geller found Antonio Fitzhugh not guilty after accepting his self-defense claim in a case arising from a June 27, 2023, non-fatal shooting outside a home on the 800 block of West Lanvale Street. That case involved a knife threat and was decided by a judge, not a jury; it does not predict the outcome of Trusty’s trial.









